Unlimited digital access from $45/mo. Print subscriptions with bound volumes available.Shop Now

Browse

View Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports by volume number

[1983] 2 VR(47 results)

Cases reported in this volume of the Victorian Reports

THE STATE OF VICTORIA v ROSSIGNOLI2 VR 1

YOUNG CJ, STARKE and FULLAGAR JJ·16 Dec 1982·

Crown lands - Licence - Statutory requirements for creation - Land Act 1958 (No. 6284), s12, s134(1)(f), s138(1)(h)

Crown lands - Licence - Promise to grant exclusive filling rights on land if other land filled and levelled - Other land filled and levelled - Whether exclusive licence created - Whether equity raised - Whether statutory requirements for creation of licence must be observed - Land Act 1958 (No. 6284), s12, s134(1)(f), s138(1)(h).

TINK v FRANCIS2 VR 17

YOUNG CJ, MCINERNEY and SOUTHWELL JJ·13 Dec 1982·

Motor vehicle - Meaning of "drive" - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325) s28, s81, s81A.

SHAW v HACKSHAW2 VR 65

YOUNG CJ, MCINERNEY and GOBBO JJ·17 Dec 1982·

Negligence - Occupier's liability - Duty of care - Trespasser - Onus of proof Person accompanying thief on farm - Occupier unaware of that person's presence - Trespasser shot by occupier - Trespass to the person.

R v SANGHERA2 VR 130

MCGARVIE J·17 Sept 1982·

Criminal law - Bail - Nature of evidence which may be taken into account Bail Act 1977 (No.9008), s8.

R v CURRAN AND TORNEY2 VR 133

MCGARVIE J·25 June 1982·

Criminal law - Evidence - Illegally obtained evidence - Discretion to exclude Admissibility of tape recordings of conversations - Nature of "prison" for purpose of Magistrates (Summary Proceedings) Act 1975 (No.8731), s68(1) and remand warrants issued pursuant thereto -Listening Devices Act 1969 (No.7804), s4, s7 - Telecommunications (Interception) Act 1979 (Cth.), s6, s7(6).

R v GIBB AND MCKENZIE2 VR 155

YOUNG CJ, CROCKETT and KING JJ·12 Nov 1982·

Criminal law - Murder - Joint trial of co accused - Application for separate trials - Discretion of judge to order separate trials - Duress - Admissibility of evidence of violent propensity by one co-accused against another.

WELSH v DONNELLY2 VR 173

YOUNG CJ, MCINERNEY and SOUTHWELL JJ·13 Dec 1982·

Criminal law - Mens rea - Statutory offence - Defence of honest and reasonable mistake of fact.

Motor vehicles - Use in contravention of terms of a special permit - Whether defence of honest and reasonable mistake of fact available - Motor Car Act 1958 (No.6325), s35.

R v WILLS2 VR 201

LUSH, MURPHY and FULLAGAR JJ·15 Feb 1983·

Criminal law - Manslaughter - Defence of self-defence - Requirement that the accused's belief be "reasonable" - Unlawful and dangerous act manslaughter - Objective nature of test - Firearms Act 1958 (No. 6251), s29D.

TL and PA FINNEGAN (TIMBER) PTY LTD v BEECHEY2 VR 215

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and MCGARVIE JJ·17 Dec 1982·

Practice and procedure - Writ of fi. fa. - Expiry - Application for renewal - Grounds for refusal - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.42, r20; O.64, r6 Practice and procedure - Writs of fi. fa. and venditioni exponas - Relationship - Rules of Supreme Court, O.42, r20; O.43, r2.

RE LYCOURESSIS RE SECOMBE2 VR 219

MURPHY J·7 Dec 1982·

Criminal law - Bail - Power of the Supreme Court to grant bail - Bail Act 1977 (No.9008) - Magistrates' Courts Act 1971 (No. 8184), s75.

TS NOMINEES PTY LTD v KRUP2 VR 227

YOUNG CJ·23 Feb 1983·

Practice and procedure - Action on dishonoured cheque - Summary procedure under Instruments Act 1958 - Action against several defendants failing to specify which was the drawer - Summary judgment not available in the action - Instruments Act 1958 (No. 6279), s4.

R v HILL2 VR 231

YOUNG CJ, MCINERNEY and SOUTHWELL JJ·13 Dec 1982·

Criminal law - Sentence - Attendance centres - Procedure to be followed by sentencing courts before making an attendance centre order - Penalties and Sentences Act 1981 (No. 9554), s36(1).

RE WILKINSON2 VR 250

CROCKETT J·30 Sept 1981·

Criminal law - Forfeiture of bail - Application to vary or rescind order - Principles governing exercise of discretion - Crown Proceedings Act 1958 (No. 6232), s5 - Bail Act 1977 (No. 9008), s31.

GOLDCEL NOMINEES PTY LTD (PROVISIONAL LIQUIDATOR APPOINTED) v NETWORK FINANCE LTD2 VR 257

MURPHY J·15 Dec 1982·

Mortgage - Mortgagee's statutory power of sale - Sale by mortgagee - Requirement to act "in good faith and having regard to the interests of the mortgagor" - Subjective element of good faith and objective standard of reasonableness of conduct required - Sale not exercised bona fide and having regard to the mortgagor's interests - Best possible price not obtained - Reserve price disclosed - Transfer of Land Act 1958 (No. 6399), s3(1), s77.

LIPERTIS v AUSTRALIAN CASUALTY COMPANY PTY LTD2 VR 280

KAYE J·15 Dec 1982·

Insurance - Disability policy - Accident - Injury - Dominant and effective cause - Meaning of "caused by accident...and resulting directly and independently of all other causes in loss".

WINDOW v THE PHOSPHATE CO-OPERATIVE CO OF AUSTRALIA LTD2 VR 287

MURPHY J·28 Apr 1983·

Environment protection - "Causing atmosphere to be polluted" - Company manufacturing superphosphate - Storing sulphur in pit - Atmosphere polluted by fire in pit - Not part of company's trade to burn sulphur - Cause of fire not ascertained or proven - Whether company caused atmosphere to be polluted - Whether discharge occurred "in the course of" company's trade - Environment Protection Act 1970 (No. 8056), s4, s41(1), s63(2).

NORDIC BANK PLC v INTERNATIONAL HARVESTER AUSTRALIA LTD2 VR 298

LUSH, MURPHY and FULLAGAR JJ·21 Feb 1983·

Companies - Scheme of arrangement - Power of court to order meetings of classes of creditors - Creditors with different types of interest - Whether appropriate to order that they constitute a separate class - Companies (Victoria) Code (No. 9712), s315.

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS) PTY LTD v COMPTROLLER OF STAMPS2 VR 305

MCGARVIE J·13 Oct 1982·

Stamp duty - Mortgage - Execution of instrument outside Victoria - Whether "relating to...any matter or thing...to be done in Victoria..." - Stamps Act 1958 (No. 6875), s17(4).

COMPOSITE BUYERS LTD v JC TAYLOR CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD2 VR 311

LUSH, MURPHY and FULLAGAR JJ·25 Feb 1983·

Practice and procedure - Third party - Self-executing order - Failure to comply - Appeal against order - Grounds of appeal.

Practice and procedure - Interlocutory order - Self-executing order - Application to Full Court for leave to appeal - Principles upon which leave is granted.

AUSTRALIAN GUARANTEE CORPORATION LTD v ROSS2 VR 319

YOUNG CJ, MURRAY and MARKS JJ·16 Dec 1982·

Hire purchase - Agreement - Defect in title of "owner" - Repossession by true owner - Rescission of agreement by hirer - Subsequent acquisition of title by lessor - Total failure of consideration - Implied terms as to title and possession - Fundamental breach.

GAMBLE v JACKSON2 VR 334

STARKE, CROCKETT and MARKS JJ·18 Apr 1983·

Companies - Investigation - Failure by officer of company to answer questions put by inspector - Whether privilege against self-incrimination available - Sufficiency of material before Court - Companies Act 1961, s175.

Evidence - Privilege against self-incrimination - Scope of privilege - Sufficiency of material before Court.

ALBION INSURANCE COMPANY LTD v BODY CORPORATE STRATA PLAN No 43032 VR 339

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and MCGARVIE JJ·24 Mar 1983·

Insurance - Public liability insurance - Condition requiring insured to take reasonable precautions to prevent bodily injury - Condition taking effect as a condition precedent - Construction of condition - Insured aware of dangerous nature of its premises - Whether onus of proof of compliance with the condition precedent satisfied.

IOANNOU v BARODA (HOLDINGS) PTY LTD2 VR 348

LUSH J·13 May 1983·

Practice and procedure - Common defence filed by solicitor acting for two defendants - Whether defendants entitled to appear by separate counsel - Counsel at trial instructed by separate solicitors - Liability of each defendant in issue - Separate interests.

Legal practitioners - Whether two defendants entitled to appear by separate counsel - Common defence filed by solicitor acting for both defendants - Counsel at trial instructed by separate solicitors - Liability of each defendant in issue - Separate interests.

COSTAIN AUSTRALIA LTD v DENNEHY2 VR 353

BROOKING J·16 May 1983·

Practice and procedure - Writ of summons under the Instruments Act 1958 - Application for leave to appear and defend - Time - Instruments Act 1958 (No. 6279), s4, Second Schedule - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.64, r8.

Practice and procedure - Writ of summons under the Instruments Act 1958 - Grant of leave to appear and defend - Application to set aside - Time - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.70, r2.

MARTIN v POLICE SERVICE BOARD MORRIS v POLICE SERVICE BOARD2 VR 357

STARKE, CROCKETT and MARKS JJ·10 May 1983·

Police - Discipline - Internal investigation of suspected disciplinary offences - Privilege against self-incrimination - Police Regulations, reg95A(7).

PAYNTER v WILLEMS2 VR 377

NICHOLSON J·13 Apr 1983·

Contract - Terms of settlement - Whether sufficient accord - Form of payment - Proffering of non-legal tender - Effect of failure of recipient to object to form of tender.

PISAK v HEGEDUS2 VR 386

MCINERNEY, MURRAY AND JENKINSON JJ·21 Aug 1980·

Practice and procedure - Public Trustee - Protected person - Relationship between Public Trustee and protected person - Sale of land on behalf of protected person - Purchasers suing protected person and Public Trustee - Whether Public Trustee properly joined - Public Trustee Act 1958 (No. 6350), s49, s50, s53, s54H and s61 - Rules of the County Court, O.8, r3 and r6.

VICTORIAN EMPLOYERS FEDERATION v REGISTRAR OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION OF VICTORIA2 VR 395

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and GOBBO JJ·12 May 1983·

Industrial law - "Industrial Matter" - Industrial Relations Commission - Award requiring notification and consultation on technological change - Validity of award - Industrial Relations Act 1979 (No. 9365), s34(1).

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S REFERENCE (No 1 of 1983)2 VR 410

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and GOBBO JJ·13 May 1983·

Criminal law - Reference by Attorney-General - Theft - Submission of no case to answer - Circumstantial evidence - Test to be applied by trial Judge - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s450A.

R v McCAUL and PALMER2 VR 419

YOUNG CJ, LUSH and BEACH JJ·21 Apr 1983·

Criminal law - Conspiracy - Evidence consistent with conspiracies other than that charged - Cross-examination as to prior convictions - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s399.

IN RE PALMDALE INSURANCE (NO 2)2 VR 430

GOBBO J·28 Jan 1983·

Insurance - Brokers and agents - Custom and usage - Insurer in liquidation - Obligation to accept net premium in satisfaction of policyholder's liability - Obligation conditional upon payment within terms of trade - Failure to pay - Repudiation - Waiver.

Insurance - Brokers and agents - Custom and usage - Whether commission component of premium held by insurer upon trust for broker.

McINTYRE v PORTER2 VR 439

ANDERSON J·30 May 1983·

Easement - Right of way - Abandonment - Non-user - Intention of owner of dominant tenement - Alternative means of access.

Practice Note of 19832 VR 448

R v LANE2 VR 449

LUSH, MURPHY and FULLAGAR JJ·22 Apr 1983·

Criminal law - Murder - Self-defence - Circumstances in which self-defence should be left to jury - Unsworn statements.

R v KENNEY2 VR 470

BROOKING J·22 Feb 1983·

Criminal law - Murder - Provocation - Acts of provocation by person other than victim - Mistaken belief that victim has provided provocation.

LYVER v STATE OF VICTORIA2 VR 475

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and MCGARVIE JJ·20 June 1983·

Crown - Liability for breach of statutory duty - "Permit" a crane to be used - Lifts and Cranes Act 1967 (No. 7629), s14(1) - Crown Proceedings Act 1958 (No. 6231), s23.

KOUTSOURADIS v KOUTSOURADIS2 VR 487

TADGELL J·19 Aug 1983·

Contract - Terms of settlement - Oral agreement - Accord executory - Discrepancy between terms of oral agreement and written confirmation of those terms - Effect - Enforceability of accord - Discretion.

Contract - Terms of settlement - Obligations imposed on third parties - Effect - Enforceability of accord by motion in the action.

R v PARSONS2 VR 499

YOUNG CJ, STARKE and KING JJ·27 June 1983·

Courts - Precedent - Interpretation of Commonwealth statute by State courts - Whether Full Court should follow decision of Full Court of another State directly in point.

Criminal law - Mens rea - Statutory offence - Whether proof of mens rea necessary - Customs Act 1901 (Cth.), s233B(1)(b).

R v CHAMBERLAIN2 VR 511

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and GOBBO JJ·31 May 1982·

Criminal law - Trafficking in a drug of addiction - Sentencing - Trial judge's view of facts - Standard of proof required.

HART v BARNES2 VR 517

ANDERSON J·25 Nov 1982·

Companies - Debenture - Assignment of present and future book debts - Whether fixed or floating charge - Priorities - Companies (Victoria) Code, s5, s331, s441, s445, s538; Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, s221C, s221P.

T V W ENTERPRISES LTD v QUEENSLAND PRESS LTD2 VR 529

O'BRYAN J·12 Apr 1983·

Companies - "Entitlement to" shares - Agreement to create pre-emptive rights to purchase shares - Whether enforceable - "Relevant interest" - "Associate" - Companies (Acquisition of Shares) (Victoria) Code - s7, s9, s11.

TERRY v MERRIVIEW PTY LTD2 VR 548

STARKE, CROCKETT and MARKS JJ·27 Apr 1983·

Sale of land - Condition in contract providing that purchaser entitled to possession and rents and profits upon acceptance of title and payment of purchase money - Late payment of residue of purchase money - Effect of condition - Whether vendor entitled to rents and profits and interest between acceptance of title and payment of purchase money.

NEVILL v HALLIDAY BRIDA v HALLIDAY2 VR 553

BROOKING J·29 June 1983·

Criminal law - Arrest - Validity - Whether unlawful trespass on property of third party affects validity of subsequent arrest - Whether maxim "every man's home is his castle" affords protection and to whom - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s458, s459A.

Trespass - Police officers - Whether implied licence to enter private property to effect an arrest - Whether maxim "every man's home is his castle" affords protection and to whom - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s458, s459A.

ESTATE AGENTS BOARD v NAKIC2 VR 570

STARKE, MURPHY and KING JJ·8 Aug 1983·

Administrative law - Statutory tribunal - Estate Agents Board - Application for grant of an estate agent's licence - Eligibility to apply for a licence - "Hearing" - Whether eligibility should be determined at, or prior to, hearing of application for grant of a licence - Consideration by the Board - Matters proper to be taken into account - "Qualifications" - Estate Agents Act 1980 (No. 9428), s14, s21.

R v WILLIAMS2 VR 579

YOUNG CJ, ANDERSON and GOBBO JJ·12 May 1983·

Criminal law - Evidence - Identification - Whether proper exercise of discretion to exclude - Duty of trial judge to direct an acquittal in identification cases.

Evidence - Identification - Whether proper excercise of discretion to exclude - Duty of trial judge to direct an acquittal in identification cases.

BRICKWOOD HOLDINGS PTY LTD v ACI OPERATIONS PTY LTD2 VR 587

KING J·19 July 1983·

Patents - Appeal from refusal to grant patent application - Purported withdrawal of opposition - Appeal allowed - Judgment not entered - Application by Commissioner of Patents to set aside judgment to enable Commissioner to reconsider intervention upon appeal - Applicable principles - Patents Act 1952 (Cth.), s60(5), s149.

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION v HORSBURGH2 VR 591

MURPHY J·10 June 1983·

Companies - Debenture - Floating charge - Provision that charge should become fixed on default - Default by company - Subsequent creation of fixed charge over present and future book debts - Appointment of receiver under first charge - Time of crystallization of floating charge - Whether "control" of property in book debts passed to receivers - Priority - Whether Commissioner of Taxation entitled to be paid group tax in priority to remuneration of receiver and debt of debenture holder - Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth.), s221P.