Unlimited digital access from $45/mo. Print subscriptions with bound volumes available.Shop Now

Browse

View Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports by volume number

[1969] VR(123 results)

Cases reported in this volume of the Victorian Reports

BEUGELAAR v CITY OF SPRINGVALEVR 3

STARKE, J·8 Aug 1968·

Practice - Writ for damages for negligence - Municipality joined as co-defendant - No leave given to bring action in Supreme Court - "Such action shall not be brought" - Summons for leave to bring action after issue and service of the writ - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s882(1), s882(2).

METROTEX PTY LTD v FREIGHT INVESTMENTS PTY LTDVR 9

WINNEKE CJ GOWANS and LUSH , JJ·25 June 1968·

Contract - Carriage of goods - Goods lost in transit - Responsibility for loss - Exemption clause in contract of carriage - Construction.

COLLINS TRADING CO PTY LTD v MAHERVR 20

LUSH, J·21 Aug 1968·

Contract - Sale of goods - Supply and installation of oil heater - "Door to door" sales - "Sale...of goods" - Affixation of goods to the land - Door to Door (Sales) Act 1963 (No. 7091), s2, s3, s6.

RAGGETT v RAGGETTVR 26

BARBER, J·19 July 1968·

Matrimonial causes - Husband's petition for divorce on ground of separation - Harsh religious beliefs of respondent - Claim for maintenance and a property settlement - "Harsh and oppressive" - "Any other reason" - Matrimonial Causes Act 1959-1966 (Com.), s37(1).

R v FLANNERY and PRENDERGASTVR 31

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and BARBER , JJ·13 Sept 1968·

Criminal law - Rape - Intention to have intercourse without consent - Accused's belief that woman was consenting party - Onus of proof on Crown to prove intent.

R v BODIVR 36

SMITH , ADAM and MCINERNEY , JJ·28 Aug 1968·

Criminal law - Evidence - Undue weight - Admission of evidence after conclusion of judge's summing-up - Discretion to allow further evidence only in exceptional circumstances.

DOTTER v EVANSVR 41

GILLARD, J·29 Apr 1968·

Specific performance - Existing judgment - Enforcement - Vesting order - Order directing Registrar of Titles to alter Register Book - All other remedies exhausted - Declaration that defendant a trustee - Trustee Act 1958 (No. 6401), s51(2), s57, 58 - Transfer of Land Act 1958 (No. 6399), s27, s28, s33, s41, s42, s103.

CASELLA v CASELLAVR 49

MCINERNEY, J·10 May 1968·

Matrimonial causes - Decree nisi ordering respondent to execute transfers and hand over duplicate certificates of title - Refusal by respondent - Committed for contempt - Direction to Registrar of Titles to cancel old and issue new certificates - All other means to be exhausted - Direction to Registrar without joining him as party - Matrimonial Causes Act 1959 (Com.), s88 (as amended by Act No. 99 of 1965), s120, s124 - Matrimonial Causes Rules, r10, r20, r259 - Transfer of Land Act 1958 (No. 6399), s103, s104(5) - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.XVI, r11; O.XLI, r5; O.XLII, r33; Divorce Rules, r152.

GRAND CENTRAL CAR PARK PTY LTD v TIVOLI FREEHOLDERSVR 62

MCINERNEY, J·9 May 1968·

Town and country planning - Open-air car park - Permit not issued - Interlocutory injunction - Unlawful use of land - Nuisance - No private cause of action for breach of Act - Action on the case - Town and Country Planning Act 1961 (No. 6849), s19.

BAILEY v WORSLEYVR 79

LUSH, J·25 Sept 1968·

Statutes - Interpretation - Unlawful damage to "a drainage channel of an Authority" - "Drainage channel" - "Of any Authority" - Management and control of channel - Water Act 1958 (No. 6413), s377.

HER MAJESTY'S ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR ENGLAND v SORATIVR 88

MENHENNITT, J·28 June 1968·

Practice - Application to substitute plaintiff - Appeal from Master's order - Additional evidence on appeal - Original plaintiff as misnomer or misdescription - Defendant must know or ought to have known - Statute of limitations - Supreme Court Rules, O.LIV, r16.

SHARP v HOTEL INTERNATIONAL LTDVR 103

NEWTON, J·31 Aug 1967·

Liquor - Licensing - Disposal - Sale of liquor - Victualler's licence - Permit to sell between 10 p.m. and 11.30 p.m. - Bona fide meal - Substantial refreshments - Liquor sold for consumption with substantial refreshments - Intention of licensee relevant - Licensing Act 1958 (No. 6293), s8(1), s8(2) - Licensing Act 1965 (No. 7319), s2 - Liquor Control Act 1968 (No. 7695), s26.

O'BRIEN v SHIRE OF ROSEDALEVR 112

GILLARD, J·17 June 1968·

Local government - Power of shire to enter lands and remove materials - Whether entry and excavations unlawful - Material not to be removed from a "park", "plantation", or within 50 yards of a "structure" - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s658, s659.

RE WINGRAVE , deceasedVR 120

LUSH, J·8 May 1968·

Administration and probate - Presumption of legitimacy - Presumption of paternity - Presumption of parenthood - No presumption of maternity - Maternity a question of fact.

WATCHORN v COMPTROLLER OF STAMPSVR 128

LITTLE, J·17 May 1968·

Stamp duties - Settlement or gift - Exemption - Superannuation fund trust instrument - Beneficiary of fund one of several trustees of estate - Trustees administering large estate - Beneficiary acting as manager of estate affairs - Whether beneficiary an officer, servant or employee of trustee - Deed and supplemental deed - Material alteration - "Officer" - "Servant or employee" - Stamps Act 1958 (No. 6375), Third Schedule, Heading IX, Exemption (4).

RICHARDS v STATE OF VICTORIAVR 136

WINNEKE CJ, ADAM and LITTLE , JJ·14 June 1968·

Tort - Liability of Crown for alleged breach of duty - Foreseeability - Teacher and pupil - Damages for injury suffered by pupil in classroom scuffle - Teacher's duty to maintain discipline - Failure to maintain class discipline on earlier occasions irrelevant - Duty to intervene in classroom fight - Duty to prevent injury to pupil

R v BOARDMANVR 151

WINNEKE, CJ GILLARD AND MENHENNITT, JJ·11 June 1968·

Criminal law - Evidence - Identification - Warning as to acceptance of identification evidence - Dangers in relying on evidence of identification.

HINCHCLIFFE v CARROLL CARROLL v HINCHCLIFFE and STOWVR 164

NEWTON, J·27 Sept 1968·

Practice - Motor-car - Actions consolidated - Cross-actions for negligence - Both defendants insured by same company - Separate legal representation party as plaintiff and as defendant - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.XIX, r15 - Wrongs Act 1958 (No. 6420), s26 - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s47, s58.

TODD v JONES JONES v PUBLIC TRUSTEEVR 169

NEWTON, J·4 Oct 1968·

Practice - Motor-car - Action by driver's widow against other driver - Subsequent action by other driver against administrator of deceased driver - Consolidation of actions - Estoppel - Supreme Court Act 1958 (No. 6387), s61(7) - Wrongs Act 1958 (No. 6420), s26 - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.XVI (A), r1(I)(c), O.XLIX, r3.

DEVENEY v STURTVR 174

WINNEKE CJ, SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·10 Oct 1968·

Local government - Authority to lay information - Prosecutions officer - Offences of a public nature - Power to prosecute as member of public - "An enactment administered by the municipality" - Summary Offences Act 1966 (No. 7405), s17, s56 - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s889 - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s91.

DUNCAN v LOWENTHALVR 180

WINNEKE CJ SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·18 Oct 1968·

County Court - Practice - Inherent and statutory power of County Court to strike out action for want of prosecution - Exercise of discretion - Inaction by plaintiff and defendant - Review by the appellate court of the exercise of discretion by the trial judge - Unavailability of witnesses - County Court Act 1958 (No. 6230), s37, s49, s78(6) - Supreme Court Act 1958 (No. 6387), s58.

CORY v CLUB MOTOR INSURANCE AGENCY PTY LTDVR 189

WINNEKE CJ, SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·11 Oct 1968·

Insurance - Motor vehicle - Comprehensive insurance - Claim for repairs - Exclusion clause in policy - Driver alleged to be under the influence of intoxicating liquor - Burden of proof - Appeal.

TELFORD PANEL and ENGINEERING WORKS PTY LTD v ELDER SMITH GOLDSBROUGH MORT LTDVR 193

LUSH, J·22 Oct 1968·

Practice - Stay of proceedings - Forum conveniens - Action brought vexatiously - Inconvenience and injustice to defendant - Inherent jurisdiction of court.

RE TESTRO BROS CONSOLIDATED LIMITED; EX PARTE ATTORNEY-GENERALVR 199

GOWANS, J·18 Nov 1968·

Companies - Liquidator of trustee company for debenture holders - Release of liquidator - Striking name of company off the register - Procedure - Notice - "Proceedings" - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s366.

R v WHITEVR 203

WINNEKE CJ, GILLARD and NEWTON , JJ·4 Dec 1968·

Criminal law - Appeal - Cross-examination as to prior convictions - Relevance - Evidence admissible but highly prejudicial - Discretion of trial judge - Miscarriage of justice - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s568(1).

RE GIGGINS, DECEASEDVR 208

GOWANS, J·21 Nov 1968·

Administration and probate - Show cause why will should not be proved - Inter- meddling in estate - Application by executors for administration with the will annexed - Renunciation by executor of probate - Administration and Probate Act 1958 (No. 6191), s15, s16.

RE PEATLING, DECEASEDVR 214

MCINERNEY, J·29 Feb 1968·

Administration and probate - Intestacy - Validity of deceased's marriage - Wife's status at time of marriage - Disappearance of first husband - Whether first husband should be presumed dead - Presumption of continuance - Presumption of innocence of crime of bigamy - Presumption of death of first husband - Presumption of validity of marriage - Children of the deceased born before marriage - Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages Act 1958 (No. 6356), s30, s31.

RE EDWARD LOVE AND COMPANY PROPRIETARY LIMITED (in voluntary liquidation)VR 230

ADAM, J·18 Nov 1968·

Companies - Retrospective operation of legislation - Ultra vires powers of company - Illegality - Unauthorized borrowing from non-shareholders - Loans agreements - Renewal of loan agreements - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s20.

RE BRUCE DAVID REALTY PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)VR 240

ADAM, J·21 Nov 1968·

Company - Liquidation - Proof of debt by bankrupt rejected by liquidator - Company guarantor of bankrupt - Whether set-off available - Mutual dealings - Bankruptcy - Rule against double proofs - Companies Act 1958 (No. 6455), s175(5) - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s237, s279 - Bankruptcy Act 1924- 1965 (Com.), s82.

RE KNIT 'N WOOL CENTRE PTY LTDVR 244

GOWANS, J·12 Nov 1968·

Company law - Meeting of creditors - Resolution that company be placed under official management - Creditors' application for the cancellation of the resolution and petition to wind up the company - Estimate of time needed to pay off debts of company - "No reasonable prospect of the company being rehabilitated" - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s211, as substituted by Companies Act 1966 (No. 7391), and s222.

RE CUTTS, DECEASEDVR 254

MCINERNEY, J·22 July 1968·

Administration and probate - Testator's family maintenance - Application by divorced wife - "Adequate provision for proper maintenance and support" - Provision for divorced wife - Considerations relevant - Administration and Probate Act 1958 (No. 6191), s91, as amended by Administration and Probate (Family Provision) Act 1962 (No. 6920).

GRATTIDGE v LIUZZI GRATTIDGE v RAMACCIOTTIVR 260

MCINERNEY, J·15 July 1968·

Public health - Adulterated food - Sale by employee - Employer and employee prosecuted - Defence of warranty - Defence of warranty not available to employee - Failure to serve notice of intention to rely on warranty on supplier - Warranty part of contract to supply goods - Health Act 1958 (No. 6270), s298, s300, s301.

JENKINS v SMITHVR 267

STARKE, J·5 Sept 1968·

Negligence - Illegal use of motor car by plaintiff and defendant - Ex turpi causa non oritur actio - Volenti non fit injuria - Public policy - Proof of conviction of offences as evidence in civil case - Evidence Act 1958 (No. 6246), s55, s56.

ATKINSON v ATKINSONVR 278

BARRY, ADAM AND MCINERNEY, JJ·18 Sept 1968·

Matrimonial causes - Ancillary relief - Division of property - Appeal - Discretion order - Appellate court, function in reviewing discretionary order - Matrimonial Causes Act 1959 (Com.), s84, s86, s87.

RE 396 BAY STREET, PORT MELBOURNEVR 293

MENHENNITT, J·17 May 1968·

Licensing - Declaration that premises are a house or place where liquor is sold without a licence authorizing such sale - Further affidavits filed by the applicant containing fresh material - Relevant only as to how the court's discretion should be exercised - Not admissible to show reasonable grounds for suspicion - Certificate of conviction admissible as evidence supporting the reasonable suspicion of the applicant - Licensing Act 1958 (No. 6293), s48.

RE 249 LATROBE STREET, MELBOURNEVR 298

PAPE, J·25 June 1968·

Gaming - Declaration that premises are used as a common gaming house - Reasonable grounds for suspicion - Not necessary to show any particular game carried on - Further affidavit filed by applicant containing fresh material not admissible - Court's discretion - Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 (No. 7429), s51.

MURTAGH v COLERAINE SEWERAGE AUTHORITYVR 306

GOWANS, J·13 Nov 1968·

Damages - Sewerage authority - Statutory duty - Breach of duty - Negligence - Nuisance - Right of court to award damages at common law - "Do as little damage as possible" - "Full compensation" - "Damages under this Act" - Sewerage Districts Act 1958 (No. 6368), s147 (as substituted by Sewerage Districts (Amendment) Act 1966 (No. 7456).

K v DVR 311

MENHENNITT, J·5 Dec 1968·

Matrimonial causes - Surname of children after dissolution of parents' marriage - Matrimonial Causes Act 1959-1966 (Com.), s23, s85, s87.

RE REID MURRAY HOLDINGS LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)VR 315

ADAM, J·19 Dec 1968·

Company law - Compulsory winding up - Summary application by official liquidator to recover money - Action by official liquidator to recover moneys - Jurisdiction - Court may grant summary relief - Discretion of court - Stay of proceedings - Inherent jurisdiction - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s293.

WOJCIC v INCORPORATED NOMINAL DEFENDANTVR 323

WINNEKE CJ, SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·25 Nov 1968·

Evidence - Admission of notes in evidence - Self-serving statements - Re-examination - Re-establishing credit in re-examination by written report.

RE METROPOLITAN FUEL PTY LTDVR 328

PAPE, J·18 Dec 1962·

Companies - Winding up - Majority of creditors opposing winding up - Just and equitable to wind up notwithstanding opposition of majority - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6389), s222, s289(1).

CONNOR v PITTAWAY MENDES v PITTAWAYVR 335

PAPE, J·25 Oct 1968·

Criminal law - Case stated - Police offences - Vagrancy - Known thief loitering in a public place "with intent to commit a felony" - Intention to commit the felony but not until substantially later - Whether it must be intended to commit the felony at time of loitering - Vagrancy Act 1966 (No.7393), s7(1)(f), s7(2).

LAMB v TOLEDO-BERKEL PTY LTDVR 343

STARKE J·26 July 1968·

Criminal law - Imposition by untrue representation - Mens rea - Knowledge of servant attributable to company - Conversion to decimal currency - Duty of magistrate to give reasons - Crimes Act 1914-1966 (Com.), s29B.

MARCH v CITY OF FRANKSTONVR 350

BARBER, J·21 Nov 1968·

Resumption and acquisition of land - Compensation - Assessment and matters affecting assessment - Factors in estimating compensation - "Solatium" - Acquisition under Local Government Act 1958 - Applicability of procedure under Valuation of Land Act 1960 - Non-applicability of principles of assessment under Valuation of Land Act 1960 - Proceedings for compensation- -Amendment of claim - Costs - Valuation of Land Act 1960 (No. 6653), s26, s29- -Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s515, s834, s836, s850.

DUNCAN v MINISTER FOR EDUCATIONVR 362

BARBER, J·27 Nov 1968·

Land - Statutes - Acquisition of land - Compensation - Valuation of land - Relevant date for valuation - Notice to treat - Cost of valuation - Valuation of Land Act 1960 (No. 6653), s29 (as amended by Valuation of Land (Appeals) Act 1965 (No. 7276) s2 - Lands Compensation Act 1958 (No. 6286), s35 - Land Act 1958 (No. 6284), s332.

Re NEW PARIS CABARETVR 366

GOWANS, J·22 Nov 1968·

Liquor - Police control of houses used for selling liquor without a licence - Declaration that house or place used for sale of liquor without licence authorizing such sale - Form of notice of application for declaration - Contents of affidavit of support of application for declaration - Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 (No.7429), s51 - Liquor Control Act 1968 (No.7695), s115.

MAHER-SMITH v GAWVR 371

WINNEKE CJ, GILLARD and NEWTON , JJ·11 Dec 1968·

Negligence - Motor vehicle collision - Conflict of evidence - No "actual persuasion" of the facts - Proof on balance of probabilities - Claim and counter-claim dismissed - Burden of proof.

CHAPPELL v A ROSS and SONS PTY LTD MACLENNAN v HASTINGS TRANSPORT PTY LTDVR 376

WINNEKE CJ, SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·25 Nov 1968·

Motor car - Employee driving in manner contrary to Act - Responsibility of employer - "Permit" - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s37H(2). Evidence - Admissions on behalf of company - Admissions made by person claiming to be managing director - Authority to make admissions - Identifying person making admissions with company.

RYAN v MILLERVR 395

WINNEKE CJ, SMITH and GOWANS , JJ·8 Oct 1968·

Justices - Order to review - Order nisi obtained but excessive delay in prosecuting it - Order filed out of time - Discharge of order nisi for want of prosecution - Discretion - No decision on merits - No appeal from order of judge - "Any determination of a single judge" - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.54, r15; O.64, r6 - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s155(3).

DARREL LEA (VIC) PTY LTD v UNION ASSURANCE SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA LTDVR 401

LUSH , J·20 Nov 1968·

Practice - Action - Trial by judge alone - Application for trial by jury - Amended defence raising new issues - Discretion - Appeal from discretionary order - Error of law - Injustice if discretion not interfered with - Onus on applicant for trial by jury - Rules of Supreme Court, O.XXXVI, r7(a); O.LIV, r16.

ROSS v SMITHVR 411

WINNEKE, CJ·25 Feb 1969·

Criminal law - Motor car - Blood alcohol exceeding .05 per cent - Breath test - Certificate in writing expressing result of test - Proof of contents of document - Notice to produce - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s81A - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A.

R v PETERSON; Ex parte HARTMANNVR 417

NEWTON, J·24 Sept 1968·

Habeas corpus - Desertion from United States Army - Deserter not a member of a visiting force - Jurisdiction of Australian service authorities - "Visiting force" - Defence (Visiting Forces) Act 1963 (Com.), s19 to s23.

JANSEN v DEWHURSTVR 421

NEWTON, J·21 June 1968·

Damages - Motor vehicle - Restitutio in integrum - Mitigation - Principles applicable - Onus of proof - Expert witness - Hearsay - Jurisdiction of court of petty sessions - Abandonment of excess - Indemnity certificate - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s68(1)(b), s85 - Appeal Costs Fund Act 1964 (No. 7117), s13.

O'DONOHUE v COMPTROLLER OF STAMPSVR 431

NEWTON, J·21 Feb 1968·

Stamp duty - Deed of settlement - Duty assessed and paid - Supplementary deeds extending period of distribution of trust funds and modifying power to revoke trust - Whether original deed gave settlor a special power of appointment - Whether supplementary deed dutiable as a fresh deed of settlement - Rule against perpetuities - Stamps Act 1958 (No. 6375), s32, s33, s89, Third Schedule, Heading IX - Property Law Act 1958 (No. 6344), s61 - Administration and Probate Act 1958 (No. 6191), s17.

R v DANAHER; EX PARTE OLZER INDUSTRIES PTY LTDVR 445

NEWTON, J·11 Sept 1968·

Justices - Inferior courts - Courts of petty sessions - Jurisdiction - Practice - Matter in which rights in future may be bound - Future rights - Ouster of jurisdiction - Parties - Infant - Necessity for next friend - Proceedings commenced without next friend - Whether a nullity - Amendment - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s68, s83 - Justices Act Rules 1963, Ch. III, r20, r21, r140.

Infants - Legal proceedings - Actions by and on behalf of infants - Necessity for next friend - Proceedings commenced without friend - Whether a nullity.

HUEBEL AND HUEBEL v HOLT AND HOLTVR 462

LUSH, J·21 Oct 1968·

Justices - Special summons - Particulars of complaint - Statement of place and bailiwick of cause of action - Not required in special summons - Default summons - Endorsement on summons contrary to rules - Not a nullity - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s3, s20, s21(1), s102(3) - Justices Act Rules 1963, ch. III, r10(2)(a), r10(2)(d), r140.

MCGIBBON v RUFFVR 468

GOWANS, J·6 Sept 1967·

Negligence - Acts defaults and omissions causing death - Under legislation based on Lord Campbell's Act - Measure of damage - Matters considered - Action by widow - Previous award of workers compensation to children of deceased in respect of same death - Fund held by Workers Compensation Board - Discretionary power in Board to make payments to widow - "Gratuity" - Workers Compensation Act 1958 (No. 6419), s9, s34, s62 - Workers Compensation Act 1965 (No. 7292), s5 - Wrongs Act 1958 (No. 6420), s19 - Wrongs (Assessment of Damages) Act 1966 (No. 7496), s2.

ENTWISLE v BALOUGHVR 471

MCINERNEY, J·19 Dec 1968·

Workers compensation - Wrongs Act - Claim at common law by widow and one child of deceased - Damages assessed by jury - Award of workers compensation in favour of other child of deceased worker - Amount of award not to be deducted from damages in common law claim - Workers Compensation Act 1958 (No. 6419), s3(2), s5(2), s26, s62, s79(3)(b), as amended by Workers Compensation (Amendment) Act 1965 (No. 7292), s11(b) and s11(c).

RE SVR 490

MCINERNEY, J·30 Aug 1968·

Infants - Adoption of children - Application to discharge adoption order - Matters for consideration - "Exceptional reason" - "Welfare and interests of the child" - Adoption of Children Act 1964 (No. 7147), s16.

RE COLLINS, deceasedVR 499

GOWANS, J·3 Dec 1968·

Administration and probate - Application for probate in solemn form of will and the contents of an envelope referred to therein - Whether application could be made by motion - Administration and Probate Act 1958 (No. 6191), s12(2)(b) - Administration and Probate Rules, r2, r17, r18, r41.

GENARDINI v ANDERTONVR 502

NEWTON, J·3 Feb 1969·

Motor car - Criminal law - Blood alcohol content exceeding .05 per cent - Breath analysis tests - Not at nearest police station - Admissibility of results - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s81A, as amended by Act No. 7593, s13 - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A, as amended by Act No. 7546, s10.

DURSTON v MERCURIVR 507

MENHENNITT, J·11 Apr 1969·

Criminal law - Motor car - Blood alcohol content exceeding .05 per cent - Breath analysis test - Certificate of result of test - Original given to defendant not produced - Carbon copy admissible as primary evidence of contents of original.

Expert evidence - Admissibility - Hearsay - Function of Supreme Court on return of order to review - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s81A - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A(1), s408A(2), s408A(2A) and s408A(3) - Crimes (Breath Analysing Instrument) Regulations 1967.

COOK v JOHNSTONVR 515

MCINERNEY, J·14 Nov 1967·

Highway - Cattle wandering - Proof of State highway - Map certified by Country Roads Board - Presumption of sealing on date indicated - Two maps read together - Country Roads Act 1958 (No. 6224), s17(1), s73(3)(a).

MOULTON v WILLIAMS MOULTON v BAXTERVR 524

MENHENNITT, J·8 Dec 1967·

Road traffic - Right of way - Failing to give way - Vehicle on left - Danger of collision - Apprehension of danger - Reasonable driver - Impossibility of compliance with regulation - Regulation inoperative - Road Traffic Regulations 1962 (as amended), reg602(3).

LUGG v DAVISVR 531

LITTLE, J·25 June 1968·

Local government - Municipal election - Recount of ballot-papers by stipendiary magistrate - Power to engage assistance in recount - Irregularities in recount - Discretion of Supreme Court, notwithstanding irregularities - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s144(3), s145, s154, s156, s157.

ASHKANASY v SHIRE OF SHERBROOKEVR 541

LUSH, J·27 Aug 1968·

Local government - Street construction - Objection to scheme - Sufficiency of notice - General nature of objections - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s577-s579.

RE MULCAHY, DECEASEDVR 545

PAPE, J·31 Oct 1968·

Will - Charity - Charitable gift to religious order for its work at a named school - Religious order no longer carrying on such work at date of testatrix's death - Failure of gift - Application cy pres.

BANK OF NEW SOUTH WALES v CITY MUTUAL LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY LTD AND STEEDVR 556

GILLARD, J·29 Nov 1968·

Mortgage - Marshalling of securities - Loan secured by first mortgage of land and assignment of life assurance policies - Second mortgage of land to secure advance by another lender - Default under first mortgage and land sold - Proceeds applied to satisfy all indebtedness to first lender - Whether proceeds of assurance policies could be applied to satisfy amount due under second mortgage - "Available in payment of his debts" - Life Assurance Act 1945-1961 (Com.), s87, s88, s90, s92(1).

FARHOOD v FARHOODVR 561

PAPE, J·18 Feb 1969·

Matrimonial causes - Maintenance pending suit - Wife living apart from husband for some years without claiming maintenance - Wife not necessarily disentitled - Principles applicable.

McLENNAN v McBROOMVR 566

WINNEKE CJ, GILLARD and NEWTON , JJ·28 Feb 1969·

Health - Sale of adulterated food - Food purchased for analysis - Division into three parts - Part retained for comparison - No evidence of condition of part retained - Health Act 1958 (No. 6270), s281, s297.

WALKER v WALKERVR 580

BARBER, J·4 Mar 1969·

Matrimonial causes - Divorce - Nullity on ground of prior marriage - Spouse absent for more than seven years - No presumption of death - False declaration of age of party to marriage - Marriage of minor - Irregularity does not invalidate marriage - Matrimonial Causes Act 1959-1966 (Com.), s18, s28(n), s38, s42, s47, s83 - Marriage Act 1961-1966 (Com.), s94 - Crimes Act 1928 (No. 3664), s61 - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231) s64.

R v FLANNERYVR 586

WINNEKE CJ, PAPE and STARKE , JJ·6 Mar 1969·

Criminal law - Rape - Corroboration of complainant's allegations - Evidence of distressed condition of prosecutrix - Charge to jury - Miscarriage of justice - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s568(1).

SOLIC v BERTOSSAVR 594

MENHENNITT J·6 Mar 1969·

Practice - Execution - Leave to issue execution where more than six years elapsed since judgment - RSC, O.42, r23.

RE BELL DECEASEDVR 597

GILLARD, J·11 Mar 1969·

Will - Interpretation - Meaning of words used to describe property - Admissibility of extrinsic evidence to explain words used.

DAJON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v TALBOTVR 603

PAPE, J·12 Mar 1969·

Injunction - Nuisance - Interlocutory injunction - Principles - Prima facie case - Balance of convenience. Town and country planning - Permit wrongly granted - Right of action by persons affected - Not necessary to join Attorney-General in action - Town and Country Planning Act 1961 (No.6849), s17-s19, s24.

SHIRE OF KNOX v McGILLIVRAYVR 617

MENHENNITT, J·13 Mar 1969·

Local government - Street construction - Objections to scheme - Order that scheme be amended by court of petty sessions - Deletion of cost of relocating PMG pits and gas mains - Beyond council's power - Objection not taken at court of petty sessions - Estoppel - Order nisi to review - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s575, s576.

WYATT v TARAX DRINKS HOLDINGS LTDVR 626

NEWTON, J·1 Apr 1969·

Lottery - Gaming - Sale of soft drinks with marked bottle tops - Additional marked bottle tops and tokens available free of charge - Competition - "Participant entitled gratuitously to participate" - All participants must be so entitled - Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 (No. 7429), s5(4)(b).

R v SYKES and CAMPI (No 1)VR 631

LUSH, J·23 Apr 1969·

Criminal law - Admissibility of self-harming statements made by accused - Made when suffering from physical, mental illness - Legally compelled to make statements.

R v SYKES and CAMPI (No 2)VR 639

LUSH, J·29 Apr 1969·

Criminal law - Procedure-Misdemeanour - Absence of accused through illness during part of proceedings - Power of court to proceed with trial in absence of accused - Right of accused to be present - Discretion of court.

LAMBERT v APPLEBYVR 641

LITTLE, J·16 May 1969·

Criminal law - Motor car - Blood alcohol content exceeding .05 per cent - Breath test - Evidence by authorized operator pursuant to s408(3)(b) - Standard alcohol solution - Cross-examination of operator showing he had no personal knowledge of constituents of solution used for testing - Prima facie case - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A, as amended by Act No. 7546, s10.

O'BRIEN v PRESIDENT, COUNCILLORS AND RATEPAYERS OF THE SHIRE OF ROSEDALEVR 645

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and MENHENNIT , JJ·16 Apr 1969·

Local government - Trespass - Trespass by public authority - Trespass ab initio - Appropriate remedy to prevent recurrence to trespass - Declaration - Injunction - Matter raised on appeal which was not taken during trial - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s658(1), s658(1A).

INSURANCE COMMISSIONER OF THE STATE MOTOR CAR INSURANCE OFFICE v MOSSVR 650

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and NEWTON , JJ·29 May 1969·

Motor car - Insurance - Driver of other car not found - Claim for personal injuries against Insurance Commissioner - Notice of special defence - Time of bringing of action - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s48(1) - Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (No. 6295), s5(6).

BAKER v MAUVR 655

LITTLE, J·30 May 1969·

Criminal law - Offence dealt with summarily - Nature of offence - Indictable misdemeanour - Felonies and misdemeanours discussed - Firearms Act 1958 (No. 6251) (as amended by Act No. 7484), s32.

R v LIQUOR CONTROL COMMISSIONVR 660

STARKE, J·19 May 1969·

Licensing - Application for restricted hotel keeper's licence - Objectors - Submission by objectors at close of applicant's case - Commission's requirement that objectors elect - Refusal to elect - Commission's refusal to state a case and to sign certificate of such refusal - Order nisi to review - Prohibition - Mandamus - Liquor Control Act 1968 (No. 7695), s3, s10, s13, s14, s15, s16, s49.

R v DAVIDSONVR 667

MENHENNITT, J·3 June 1969·

Criminal law - Unlawful use of an instrument to procure a miscarriage- -Necessary to preserve the woman from serious danger - Honest and reasonable belief of accused - Act not out of proportion to danger to be averted - Onus of proof - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s65.

PORTER v HANNAH BUILDERS PTY LTD THOMPSON v HANNAH BUILDERS PTY LTDVR 673

LUSH, J·9 Oct 1968·

Building contract - Arbitration clause - Right of builder to be upon land - Licence - Termination - Arbitration clause - Determination of licence independently of terms of agreement - Stay of proceedings - Arbitration Act 1958 (No. 6200), s5. Injunction - Interlocutory - Relevant considerations - Actions by Crown. Crown - Lands vested in Minister - Right of Minister to grant and determine licences to be upon land - Public Lands and Works Act 1964 (No. 7228), s8.

POBEZIN v INSURANCE COMMISSIONER OF THE STATE MOTOR CAR INSURANCE OFFICEVR 682

MENHENNITT, J·24 Mar 1969·

Motor car - Unsatisfied judgment - A claim against insurer - Statute limiting liability to $4000 in respect of "any claim...made by or in respect of any passenger" - Claims by widow and children for death of husband - Whether liability of insurer limited to $4000 in respect of all such claims - Whether only one claim is provided for by the widow and children under the Wrongs Act 1958, PtIII - Liability of authorized insurer for costs - Motor Car Act 1958 (No.6325), s42, s46(2)(a), s47 - Motor Car (Compulsory Third Party Insurance) Act 1967 (No. 7648), s2(1)(a), s3(2) - Wrongs Act 1958 (No. 6420), s16, s17, s20-s22, s24 - Acts Interpretation Act 1958 (No. 6189), s17.

Judgment - Action based upon statute - Claim made for larger sum than that awarded - Whether interest allowed on judgment or costs - Whether claims were for debts or sums certain - Separate claims and the amount apportioned to each plaintiff not determined until judgment entered - Supreme Court Act 1958 (No. 6387), as amended by Act No. 6874 of 1962, s78-s79A.

R v WILLIAMSONVR 696

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and MENHENNITT , JJ·11 Apr 1969·

Criminal law - Presentment for unlawful and indecent assault - Whether verdict of common assault available as alternative verdict - Defence of consent - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s55.

BOYLE v WRIGHTVR 699

SMITH, J·28 Apr 1969·

Weights and measures - Underweight goods - "Accident" - "Mistake" - Weights and Measures Act 1958 (No. 6414), s92, as amended by Act No. 7531.

PLACE v WILLIAMSVR 703

STARKE, J·16 May 1969·

Practice - Appearance - Entry of by mistake - Right of solicitor of his own motion to amend appearance or strike it from the record.

A WHITE v MOLONEY K WHITE v PETERSEN SLATER v WILLIAMSONVR 705

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and MENHENNITT , JJ·24 Apr 1969·

Criminal law - Motor car - Blood alcohol content exceeding .05 per cent - Breath analysis test - Certificate of result of test - Document purporting to be a copy - "Purporting" carbon copy not described as "copy" - Delivery of document to defendant after certification thereof - Whether impossible to comply with requirements of Act - Whether certificate admissible - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s81A - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A, as amended.

DEPOSIT and INVESTMENT CO LTD v GREENAWAYVR 714

LITTLE, J·25 Nov 1968·

Money lender - Joint and several covenant to repay - Statute requiring memorandum of contract to be signed by "the borrower", and copy to be sent to "the borrower" - Memorandum not signed by and copy not sent to all persons to whom money lent - Action against borrower who did sign and receive copy - Whether enforceable against such person - Subsequent amendment to legislation - Effect of - Provision affecting substantive rights - Money Lenders Act 1958 (No. 6324), s3, s23 - Money Lenders (Amendment) Act 1961 (No. 6819), s2, s5.

R v HADLANDVR 725

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and GILLARD , JJ·4 June 1969·

Criminal law - Appeal - Conduct of trial - Defence of alibi - Other evidence available to defence but not called - Decision of counsel not to call such evidence - Probability of "miscarriage of justice" - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s568(1).

CREELY v INGLESVR 732

LITTLE, J·16 May 1969·

Criminal law - Motor car - Blood alcohol exceeding .05 per cent - Breath test - Delivery of Schedule 7A certificate as soon as practicable - Information dismissed - Misdirection on part of stipendiary magistrate as to meaning and application of words "as soon as practicable" - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s408A, as amended by Act No. 7546, s10.

R v DEVENISHVR 737

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and GILLARD , JJ·6 June 1969·

Criminal law - Larceny as a clerk or servant, fraudulent conversion and false pretences - Alleged false receipt and a document in similar handwriting lost by Crown after committal proceedings and before trial - Application by Crown after commencement of trial to lead secondary evidence, inter alia, of contents of both documents - Admissibility - Considerations affecting exercise of judge's discretion to admit such evidence - Evidence Act 1958 (No. 6246), s148.

RENOWDEN v MCMULLIN AND HEALEVR 744

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and NEWTON , JJ·24 June 1969·

Practice - Amendment - Endorsement on writ superseded by delivery of statement of claim - Application to amend statement of claim - Statute-barred cause of action sought to be introduced by amendment - Statement of claim relevant document - RSC, O.3, r1; O.18(A), r5; O.19, r4; O.20, r2.

CARR v WALUKICIWICKVR 758

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and GILLARD , JJ·30 June 1969·

Motor car - Driving with excess percentage of alcohol in blood - Driving under the influence - No evidence that driving done on a highway - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s80B and s81A (as amended by Act No. 7593, s13) - Crimes (Driving Offences) Act 1967 (No. 7645), s5 and s7.

RE HEMBURROWVR 764

GILLARD, J·30 May 1969·

Administration and probate - Omission of phrase from will - Jurisdiction to grant probate of will textually different from that signed by testatrix.

WATTS v WATTSVR 767

NEWTON, J·13 May 1968·

Husband and wife - Property - Shares transferred by husband to wife - Intention - Jointly owned property - Creation of house thereon - Rights of parties - Scope of Court's discretion - "Just and equitable" - Marriage Act 1958 (No. 6306), s161 - Marriage Property Act 1962 (No.6924), s3.

WALKER v WILLISVR 778

LUSH, J·22 Oct 1968·

Trusts and trustees - Duties of trustees - Shares held upon trust for beneficiary contigently upon his attaining 25 - Trustees holding other shares in own right - Trustees directors of company - Annual meeting called just before vesting of beneficiary's interest to prevent his exercising voting rights - Injunction to restrain. Companies - Directors - Shareholders - Shares held by directors on trust for beneficiary contigently upon his attaining 25 - Shares also held by directors in own right - Annual meeting called just before beneficiary's interest to prevent his exercising voting rights - Directors duties - Standing of beneficiary to apply for injunction.

SPRINGVALE WASHED SAND PTY LTD v CITY OF SPRINGVALEVR 784

MCINERNEY, J·4 Nov 1968·

Local government - By-law empowering council to require applicant for sand excavation permit to enter an agreement and pay royalties - Power to make by-law "for the purposes" of "prohibiting regulating or controlling excavation operations" - Whether by-law and agreement made thereunder invalid - Whether permit issued invalid - Severability of by-law and agreement considered - Whether agreement was one for the payment of a "composition" under s541 of the Local Government Act 1946 - Shire of Dandenong by-law 85 - Shire of Dandenong and Noble Park by-law 127 - Local Government Act 1946 (No. 5203), s197(1)(xxxv), s198, s334, s335, s534, s541 - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s197(1)(xxxv), s198, s336, s337, s535, s542.

Money had and received - Money paid under illegal agreement - Money paid voluntarily and not under coercion - Plaintiff's belief that money could not lawfully be demanded - Claim for repayment.

KEOGH v HOUSING COMMISSION OF VICTORIAVR 809

BARBER, J·2 May 1969·

Acquisition of land - Claim for compensation against Housing Commission of Victoria - Claim by lessee for disturbance - Whether claimant "person displaced" - Whether inconsistency between provisions of the Lands Compensation Act 1958 and Housing Act 1958, s102 - Whether power to make ex gratia payments by Commission precludes claim for compensation pursuant to Lands Compensation Act - Valuation of Land Act 1960 (No. 6653) - Housing Act 1958 (No.6275), s99-s102 - Lands Compensation Act 1958 (No. 6286), s3, s59-s61.

GROSS v SHIRE OF SOUTH BARWONVR 815

BARBER, J·30 May 1969·

Land compensation - Compensation consequent upon reservation of land under planning scheme - Limitation of right to claim - Which statute applicable - Statutory interpretation - Town and Country Planning Act 1961 (No. 6849), s41 and s42 - Local Government Act 1958 (No. 6299), s835 - Valuation of Land (Appeals) Act 1965 (No. 7276), s12 - Valuation of Land Act 1960 (No. 6653), s27.

TOTAL (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED v REGISTRAR OF COMPANIESVR 821

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and NEWTON , JJ·20 May 1969·

Companies - Foreign company - Increase in capital in 1960 - Notice filed in 1965- What fees due to Registrar of Companies - Companies Act 1958 (No. 6455), s6(6), s9, s264, s296(2), s302 - Companies (Fees) Act 1960 (No. 6627), s3 - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s4(1) and s4(2), s7(11), s347(2) and Second Schedule - Acts Interpretation Act 1958 (No. 6188), s7(2).

RE CARROLL DECEASED BENJAMIN v COMMISSIONER OF PROBATE DUTIESVR 826

MENHENNITT, J·3 July 1969·

Probate duty - Interest of deceased in partnership - Partnership property outside Victoria - Whether "personal property" - Contrary intention - Probate Duty Act 1962 (No. 6890), s7(1)(b).

ANSTIS v THOMASVR 836

LITTLE, J·11 June 1969·

Road traffic - Parking infringement - Parking area "off-street" - Procedure under s12 - Defendant not electing to appear - Whether permissible for stipendiary magistrate to hear oral evidence as to alleged offence - Whether defendant deprived of right to challenge conviction - Road Traffic Act 1958 (No. 6359), s4, s12 - Road Traffic Regulations 1962, reg102, reg1101.

RE GOLDSWORTHYVR 843

SMITH, J·28 June 1968·

Probate duty - First Schedule - Assessment - Mode of assessing duty in relation to discretionary trust created by will - Successive interests - Probate Duty Act 1962 (No. 6890), s4, s6, First Schedule.

TURNER v CIAPPARAVR 851

MCINERNEY, J·11 June 1969·

Road traffic - Traffic control signal - Signal jammed on red - Driver entering intersection against red light - Whether a signal "by which traffic capable of being controlled" - Road Traffic Regulations 1962, reg102 and reg401

R v EVANS AND LEWISVR 858

O'BRYAN , SMITH and LITTLE , JJ·1 May 1963·

Criminal law - Murder - Direction that charge against one accused was that of murder or nothing and that verdict of manslaughter not open - Whether manslaughter open upon the evidence - Such defence not relied upon at the trial - Jury's verdict negating possibility of conviction for manslaughter - Failure to direct as to an alternative verdict for a lesser offence not necessarily a miscarriage of justice - Evidence of a previous shooting by accused on the day in question - Whether such evidence relevant - Prejudice - Granting of separate trials - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s568.

AF and G ROBINSON v EVANS BROS PTY LTDVR 885

STARKE, J·29 Nov 1968·

Insurance - Public liability policy - "Accidental damage arising out of an accident" - Maxim "verba chartarum fortius accipiuntur contra proferentem" - Knowledge of risk of damage - Unintended or unexpected event - Non-disclosure.

MCKINNON v BURTATOWSKI and YELLOW CABS OF AUSTRALIA PTY LTDVR 899

PAPE, J·22 Nov 1968·

Negligence - Duty of care - Duty to take affirmative action - Creation of hazard on roadway - Due to other road-users - Non-feasance - Misfeasance.

LOUGHRIDGE v LAVERYVR 912

ADAM, J·19 June 1969·

Sale of land - Contract of sale - Default by purchaser - Elements involved - Inability to proceed - Desire to do so - Waiver - Acceptance of repudiation - Resale by vendor - Duty to purchaser on resale.

H C SLEIGH LTD v BLIGHTVR 931

ADAM, J·8 July 1969·

Injunction - Interlocutory - Application to delay registration of transfer of land - Application to restrain the sale of certain goods - Pending trial - Principles applicable - Whether plaintiff would be likely to succeed in the action - Whether application too late to preserve the status quo pending the trial. Tort - Wrongful interference with contractual rights - Third-party contracts to purchase property from contract breaker - No prior notice that vendor bound by a trading agreement with the plaintiff - Third party not exercising right to rescind contract - Whether cause of action exists.

BLACKALL v TROTTER (NO 1)VR 939

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and MENHENNITT , JJ·29 May 1969·

Legal profession - Costs - Solicitor for the Insurance Commissioner acting for defendant in motor car action - Defendant having policy of insurance with Insurance Commissioner - Plaintiff ordered to pay defendant's taxed costs - Solicitor employed by the Crown and not the holder of a practicing certificate - Defendant not liable to the solicitor for costs - Whether costs payable by the plaintiff to the defendant - Whether the Crown and its employees bound by PtV of the Legal Profession Practice Act 1958 - Whether solicitor engaged in practice as a solicitor on his own account - Validity of declaration by Council of the Law Institute - Workers Compensation Act 1958 (No. 6419), s65(2) - Public Service Act 1958 (No. 6349), s31(1) - Motor Car Act 1958 (No. 6325), s72, s74(1) - Legal Profession Practice Act (No. 6291), s51(1), s88(2), s90, s93.

BLACKALL v TROTTER (No 2)VR 946

WINNEKE CJ, LITTLE and MENHENNITT , JJ·8 July 1969·

Appeal costs fund - Practice - Application to review a taxation of costs by the Taxing Master - Matter referred to the Full Court - Decision of Taxing Master set aside - Application by unsuccessful respondent for an indemnity certificate - Whether application could be granted - Whether such review constitutes an "appeal" from the decision of a "court" within the meaning of the Appeal Costs Fund Act 1964 - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.65, r27(39), r27(40), r27(41) Supreme Court Act 1958 (No. 6387) s7(4) - Appeal Costs Fund Act 1964 (No. 7117), s2, s13, s13(1).

LEE v LOETSCH LEE v PANOZZOVR 949

MENHENNITT, J·6 May 1968·

Practice - Order to review - Court of petty sessions dismissing information - Application for order nisi made to a judge in chambers - Whether application must be made to the Master - Whether the Master constitutes the Supreme Court - Validity of the Supreme Court Rules authorizing Masters to determine applications for the granting of orders nisi to review considered - Supreme Court Act 1958 (No. 6387) s6, s7(1), s7(4), s25(j)(i), s185(1) Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s155(1) - Rules of the Supreme Court, O.54, r14(d), r15(1)(a), r17.

R v WEISEVR 953

BARRY, SMITH AND ADAM, JJ·12 Mar 1969·

Criminal law - Murder - Verdict of guilty - Power of Full Court on appeal to quash sentence and substitute a verdict of not guilty on the ground of insanity - Power exercisable where no ground of appeal established - Power independent - Discussion of M'Naghten Rules - Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231), s568(1) and s569(4).

RE YOUNG'S HORSHAM GARAGE PTY LTD (In Liquidation)VR 977

MENHENNITT, J·27 Oct 1967·

Company law - Winding up - Sales tax - Proposed action by Commonwealth against company in liquidation - State Act requiring leave to commence proceedings - "Crown" bound by Act - Whether Crown in right of Commonwealth bound. Constitutional law - Application of State laws - Question of construction of State Act - No inter se question raised - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s216, s217, s263 - Judiciary Act 1903-1966 (Com.), s40A, s79.

RE K REES EMPORIUMS LTDVR 981

GILLARD, J·18 June 1969·

Companies - Application for order for meeting of creditors - Proposed scheme of arrangement - Scheme not bona fide for benefit of creditors - Service of notice on other creditors - Court's discretion to refuse to make order - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s181(1).

TAYLOR v MILLERVR 987

WINNEKE CJ, GOWANS and GILLARD , JJ·30 June 1969·

Negligence - Road accident - Collision at street intersection - Giving way to vehicle on the right - Relevance of Road Traffic Regulations - Jury apportionment - Reasonableness - Damages - Whether excessive - Use to be made of actuarial evidence - Road Traffic Regulations 1962, reg601, reg602.

RE BRIGHT PINE MILLS PTY LTDVR 1002

O'BRYAN , SMITH and PAPE , JJ·27 Sept 1963·

Company - Winding up petition - "Oppressive" conduct of company - Member of private company deprived of directorship and benefits of profitable undertakings of new "subsidiary" firm - Alternative remedy in cases of oppression - Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s186.

MCMASTER v GILESVR 1015

GOWANS, J·10 Sept 1969·

Local government - Sale of adulterated food to local officer - Offence of a public nature - Power to purchase and submit food for analysis as member of public - Power to prosecute as member of public - Health Act 1958 (No. 6270), s238.

BARNES v GOUGOUSISVR 1019

ADAM, J·20 Aug 1969·

Criminal law - Justices Act - Summary jurisdiction - Informant absent at first hearing - Application for summary jurisdiction - Plea of not guilty by counsel for defendant - Application by prosecutor for adjournment refused - Submission to dismiss information for want of prosecution - Application by prosecutor to appear for informant pursuant to Justices Act 1958, s205 - Information dismissed for want of prosecution - Second hearing commenced with committal proceedings - Application for summary jurisdiction granted - Plea of not guilty through counsel - Plea of autrefois acquit upheld - Order to review - Autrefois acquit - Elements required - Prosecutor entitled to appeal - Justices Act 1958 (No. 6282), s91(2) and s91(10), s102B, s205.