Unlimited digital access from $45/mo. Print subscriptions with bound volumes available.Shop Now

Browse

View Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports by volume number

[1954] VLR(104 results)

Cases reported in this volume of the Victorian Reports

McNEE v. BARROW BROS. COMMISSION AGENCY PTY. LTD.VLR 1

SHOLL J. read the following judgment·25 Feb 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marketing of primary productsEggs and egg pulp — Eggs both cracked and sound imported into Victoria from New South Wales — Cracked eggs intended for pulping and sale as egg pulp — Eggs cracked in transport and in re-grading after, journey, together with some sound eggs, also pulped — Regulation prohibiting conversion of eggs to whole egg pulp without consent of Egg and Egg Pulp Marketing Board — Whether regulation invalid or ultra vires — Marketing of Primary Products Act 1935 (No. 4337), secs. 16, 18, 19, 43; Marketing of Primary Products (Validation) Act 1939 (No. 4658); Egg and Egg Pulp Marketing Board Regulations 1941, reg. 47 (e); Commonwealth Constitution, sec. 92.

BIRD v. WARDVLR 20

FULL COURT (Lowe A.-C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·24 Aug 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

WrongsContributory negligence — Both plaintiff and defendant to blame for collision — Difficulty in apportioning blame — Duty of Court to apportion responsibility — Wrongs (Contributory Negligence) Act 1951 (No. 5594), sec. 3.

WILKS v. HOWEYVLR 22

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·20 Apr 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

PartnershipDissolution — Accounts — Advances by partner beyond amount of capital agreed to be subscribed — Drawings — Computation of interest on advances — Interest on overdrawings — When payable — Partnership Act 1928 (No. 3745), sec. 28 (3).

HAWTHORN v. BARTHOLOMEWVLR 28

GAVAN DUFFY J. read the following judgment·2 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

HealthOffence — In possession of carcass or meat not branded — Ingredients of offence — Mental element not relevant — Possession through servant sufficient — Honest and reasonable belief that carcass or meat branded not a defence — Health Act 1928 (No. 3697), sec. 288.

KINGSTON v. CITY OF CHELSEAVLR 33

GAVAN DUFFY J. read the following judgment·9 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Local governmentScheme of street construction — Power to drain streets — Not limited to area of street itself — Inclusion within scheme of unauthorized streets — Scheme invalidated — Unless inclusion incidental to bon fide scheme — Local Government Act 1946 (No. 5203), Part XIX, Div. 10.

FOENANDER v. DABSCHECKVLR 38

HUDSON A. J. read the following judgment·21 Apr 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantRecovery of possession of premises — Tenant overholding after expiry of original term — Subsequent agreement — Nature of tenancy — Evidence supporting magistrate's decision — Payment of rent in advance after the date of expiration of notice to quit — Rent paid to a date after the date of commencement of hearing — No evidence of a new tenancy — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), sec. 54.

R. v. COLLINSVLR 46

SHOLL J. read the following judgment·17 July 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Contempt of CourtWhether can be committed by duly stamped affidavit handed to associate for Judge, but not read aloud — When affidavit is "filed" — Abuse of counsel and solicitors by affidavit — When amounting to contempt — Challenge to validity of appointment of Acting-Judge — Method of challenge — Whether relevancy is defence to charge of contempt — Power to remove contemptuous affidavits from file — Reasons for non-removal — Modified order preventing disclosure without Court order — Supreme Court Act 1928 (No. 3783), secs. 11, 33.

PRITCHARD v. MELBOURNE AND METROPOLITAN TRAMWAYS BOARDVLR 60

MARTIN, J. read the following judgment·31 July 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

WrongsPractice — Running down action — Claim for damages for personal injury and for damage to plaintiff's motor vehicle — Contributory negligence of plaintiff — Jury finding for plaintiff but finding plaintiff ninety per cent responsible for collision — Award of jury scaling down assessment of general damages by ninety per cent but omitting to reduce special damages — Jury further directed and retiring — On returning jury increasing assessment of damages so that award originally arrived at represented one-tenth of total new assessment — Assessment of damages before reducing by ninety per cent unreasonably high — Whether judgment should be pronounced for original award on incorrect basis or final award — Judgment entered for increased assessment — Costs — How to be awarded — Wrongs (Contributory Negligence) Act 1951 (No. 5594).

R. v. PRICES COMMISSIONERVLR 64

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Barry and Dean JJ.).·18 Aug 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Prices regulationDeclared goods — Commissioner to fix maximum price or rate at which any declared goods may be sold — Commissioner to so fix the maximum price within fourteen days of application — Whether an application can be made when maximum price has previously been fixed by Commissioner — Prices Regulation Act 1948 (No. 5310), secs. 9, 14.

SULLIVAN v. SULLIVANVLR 67

SHOLL, J. delivered the following judgment·14 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceHabitual drunkenness and cruelty — Definition of "habitual drunkard" — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), sec. 75 (b).

IN RE DAWESVLR 76

MARTIN, J. read the following judgment·24 July 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

TrustsTenant for life and remainderman — Rates and taxes — Whether life tenant or remainderman should pay — Repairs — Where no power in trustee to execute — Should apply to Court in case of salvage.

Settled landAbortive sale — Expenses of — Whether tenant for life entitled to out of capital moneys — Settled Land Act 1928 (No. 3771), secs. 38, 73.

GOGEL v. LAMBIEVLR 83

FULL COURT (Lowe A.-C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·21 Aug 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantPrescribed premises — Offences — Receiving as rent sum "irrecoverable" by virtue of Act — Rent fixed as at December 1940 — Premises then unfurnished — Later furnished — Same prescribed premises — Identity is substantial identity — Meaning of "irrecoverable" — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 12, 23, 24, 29 (2).

JONES v. VINCEVLR 88

MARTIN, J. read the following judgment·12 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

JusticesDirection for detention in reformatory prison during Governor's pleasure — Whether a summary conviction — Whether a term of imprisonment imposed — Right of appeal to General Sessions — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), sec. 136 (a).

BARSON v. BARSONVLR 93

FULL COURT (Lowe A.-C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·18 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorcePractice — Adultery between respondent and co-respondent after service of sealed copy petition and copy citation — Supplemental petition — No citation in respect thereof issued — Whether jurisdiction to grant decree nisi on supplemental petition.

DivorcePetitioner domiciled in Victoria for two years and upwards at time of hearing of the petition — Not so domiciled at time of institution of the suit — Supplemental petition to be filed — Such petition an independent proceeding.

DivorcePetition presented and proceedings instituted under Part III of the Commonwealth Matrimonial Causes Act 1945 — Proceedings intituled as if presented under Part II of the Commonwealth Matrimonial Causes Act 1945 — Amendment of petition.

MORRISS v. WITHERSVLR 100

MARTIN, J.·30 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Contempt of CourtConditions precedent to exercise of power — Notice of charge to be explained to accused — Opportunity of making explanation to be afforded — "Wilful prevarication" — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), sec. 206.

EVA v. EVAVLR 105

GAVAN DUFFY, J. read the following judgment·30 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceDesertion — Clauses in agreement executed between husband and wife — "The husband and the wife shall not molest annoy or in any way whatever interfere with each other in respect of anything whatever" — "Nor shall either of them at any time during the continuance of the agreement require or by any means endeavour to compel the other to cohabit with him or her" — Effect on desertion.

CITY OF NUNAWADING v. SMITHVLR 108

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·22 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

HealthConstruction of drain — Apportionment of cost of drain — Water from land not situate in subject street running into drain — Whether owners of such land liable to contribute to cost of drain — Health Act 1928 (No. 3697), sec. 63.

THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES v. WATSONVLR 111

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy and O’Bryan JJ., and Hudson A.-J.).·30 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

CostsTaxation — Crown counsel — Who salaried officers and received no separate fee — Fees not vouched by counsel's signature — Must be disallowed — Rules of the Supreme Court 1938, Order LXV, r. 27 (52).

MANENTI v. MELBOURNE AND METROPOLITAN TRAMWAYS BOARDVLR 115

SHOLL, J.·27 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidenceNegligence — Child injured — Contributory negligence alleged — Boarding moving tram-cars — Evidence that previously warned of danger — Admissible — When evidence admitted as facta probabilia — Principle in criminal cases — That admissible evidence which of little weight and possibly unfairly prejudicial to accused should be excluded — No application in civil cause.

R. v. TWISTVLR 121

FULL COURT (Martin, Dean and Smith JJ.).·11 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawEvidence — Assault with intent to rob — Conversation by accused, with person alleging assault, offering "protection" for a weekly payment — Conversation occurring a few days before alleged assault — Admissibility — Failure of accused to answer questions after warning — Not evidence of guilt.

R. v. WILLIAMSVLR 134

FULL COURT (Herring C.J., Lowe and Martin JJ.).·9 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawReceiving — Doctrine of recent possession — Meaning of doctrine — Proof of recent possession — Whether evidence of admissions sufficient — Evidence consistent only with recent possession — Direction that jury might act on such evidence though not finding recent possession — Direction upheld.

R. v. McNAMARAVLR 137

FULL COURT (Martin, Dean and Smith JJ.).·7 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

AssaultThreat of violence — Threat must create fear of violence — Jury to be so directed.

R. v. HODGKINSONVLR 140

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Barry and Dean JJ.).·1 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawNew trial — Juror speaking to detective-witness at luncheon adjournment during trial — Verdict on presentment brought in by jury and accepted by trial Judge — Prisoner bringing to notice of trial Judge conversation between detective-witness and juror — Juror and detective questioned by trial Judge on substance of conversation — Jury finally discharged — Discretion of trial Judge to discharge jury — Power of Full Court to set aside verdict of guilty and order new trial — Power of trial judge to recall witness, after close of evidence, in response to request by jury.

STATE SAVINGS BANK (VIC.) v. ROGERS BROS.VLR 149

DEAN, J.·25 Nov 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Justices"Order" — Ruling that evidence inadmissible — Complaint adjourned — For purpose of testing ruling — Ruling not a reviewable "order" — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), secs. 4, 150.

Landlord and tenantCosts — Order nisi set aside — No power to award costs — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), sec. 58.

R. v. LIGHTVLR 152

SHOLL J.·29 Jan 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawBail — Discretion to grant — Considerations applicable.

EQUITY TRUSTEES EXECUTORS & AGENCY CO. LTD. v. RIDDELLVLR 161

SHOLL J. read the following judgment·14 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Settled landImprovements — Interpretation of Second Schedule to Settled Land Act — Powers of Court under the Act considered — Principles to be applied in determining whether proposed works are improvements or not — Principles to be applied to resolve conflict when work falls within more than one part of Second Schedule — Effect on powers of trustees and tenants for life of covenant by tenant for life to effect repairs other than structural repairs — Settled Land Act 1928 (No. 3771), secs. 84-92.

BOOTH v. PUBLIC TRUSTEEVLR 183

HUDSON A., -J. read the following judgment·31 Mar 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Public TrusteeAuthority to apply for probate — Powers and duties of Public Trustee prior to grant of probate — Public Trustee appointing valuator in accordance with terms of will before grant of probate and selling trust property to beneficiary with option of purchase on basis of such valuation — Whether breach of trust — Whether sale justified as being for purposes of administration or for purpose of distribution of purchase money to beneficiaries under terms of will — Whether Public Trustee must advert to necessity for sale in order that sale be protected as necessary for purposes of distribution — Whether Public Trustee's acts protected as those of executor de son tort — Whether beneficiary purchasing with notice of breach of trust able to rely on fact of dealing bon fide with Public Trustee — Public Trustee Act 1939 (No. 4654), sec. 62 — Public Trustee Act 1940 (No. 4755), sec. 3 — Administration and Probate Act 1928 (No. 3632), sec. 39 (1) (b).

WillConstruction — Sale of trust property to be at price determined by sworn valuator "appointed by my trustees" — Executors appointed by will authorizing Public Trustee to apply for probate in their stead — Public Trustee appointing valuator after authorization but before grant of probate — Whether valuator "appointed by my trustees".

KERTESZ v. KERTESZVLR 195

SHOLL J. read the following judgment·9 Nov 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceDomicil — Deserted wife — Effect of insanity on domicil — Effect of insanity on actual desertion and constructive desertion — Rejection of argument that less surviving mental capacity may be sufficient to support a finding of constructive rather than actual desertion — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), sec. 75.

ZACHER v. ZACHERVLR 204

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy and O’Bryan JJ. and Hudson A.J.).·14 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

MaintenanceWife in Victoria — Husband in another State — "Leaves without means of support" — Physical movement not relevant — Maintenance Act 1928 (No. 3722), sec. 63.

AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANK LTD. v. RAYVLR 209

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·10 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantRecovery of possession — Where tenant does not contend proceedings — Whether sub-tenant's hardship can be considered — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 45 (1), 56 (4).

EDWARDS v. JOYCEVLR 216

SHOLL, J.·27 May 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

EstoppelJoint tortfeasors — Negligence — Collision between car and truck — Action by passenger in car against car and truck drivers — Verdict for plaintiff — Apportionment of damages as between defendants assessed as to three-fourths against truck driver and as to one-fourth against car driver — Subsequent action by another passenger in car against truck driver and his employers — Truck driver driving at time of collision in course of his employment — Car driver joined by truck driver and his employers as third party — Whether defendants bound in subsequent action by previous apportionment of damages in earlier action — Issue estoppel — Whether issues in later action substantially the same as issues in earlier action — Wrongs (Tortfeasors) Act 1949 (No. 5382), sec. 2.

FURSDON v. McGOVERNVLR 231

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Barry and Dean JJ.).·19 Aug 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Motor carUsed on highway without being registered — Self-propelled mechanical grab used for picking up and carrying objects from place to place — Whether a "motor car" — Whether a "vehicle" — Grab being driven unloaded by owner's employee on public road to maker's premises where demonstration of its qualities to be given to prospective purchaser — Whether being "used" on highway — Motor Car Act 1951 (No. 5616), secs. 3, 17.

GALT v. BURNHAMVLR 235

HUDSON, A., -J. read the following judgment·16 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Local GovernmentSection creating offence — Obstructing council or its employee — In performance of anything empowered or required to do — "By this or any other Act" — Employee obstructed in performing something empowered to do by regulations made under Act — Non-application of section — Local Government Act 1946 (No. 5203), sec. 856.

IN RE HARTVLR 239

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·29 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

TrustsPowers of trustees — Preferential right to subscribe for further shares in company — Shares may be retained — Bonus shares received gratis — Held on same trusts as original holding — Whether Court has power to sanction breach of trust already committed — Trustee Act 1928 (No. 3792), secs. 10, 57.

IN RE PRODUCERS’ DEFENCE FUNDVLR 246

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·5 May 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Voluntary associationDissolution — Appointment of trustees of funds — Fund in hand — Moneys subsequently received by trustees — Charitable trust not created — Trust infringing rule against perpetuities — No resulting trust — Fund and moneys passing to Crown as bona vacantia.

SHEPPARD v. UNITED STEVEDORING PTY. LTD.VLR 257

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy and O’Bryan JJ. and Hudson A.-J.).·15 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Workers' compensationAccident to worker — Causing injuries to arm and head — Whether compensation to be assessed separately — Or at one amount in respect of one injury — Method of assessment — Workers' Compensation Act 1951 (No. 5601), secs. 5, 9, 11.

GOMARSALL v. YOLEVLR 269

FULL COURT (Lowe A.-C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·31 Aug 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

NegligenceContributory negligence — Motor car collision — Applicability of doctrine of last opportunity.

PEAK v. VAN DER KOLKVLR 276

O’BRYAN, J. read the following judgment·9 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantRecovery of possession — Notice to quit — Premises reasonably required for occupation of lessors, and premises reasonably required for demolition and reconstruction — Subject premises let as dwelling-house required by lessors for use in connexion with lessors' business — Consent of Minister administering Building Operations and Building Materials Control Act 1952 not obtained at date of proceedings — Whether grounds of notice to quit valid — Whether Minister's consent required at date of proceedings — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), sec. 37 (5) (g) (i), (m) — Building Operations and Building Materials Control Act 1946 (No. 5116), sec. 3 — Building Operations and Building Materials Control Act 1952 (No. 5650), sec. 2.

DARROCH v. DENNISVLR 282

SHOLL, J.·9 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

WrongsDamages suffered by widow and child — Benefit from husband's estate received by widow, but not by child — Method of assessing damages — Wrongs Act 1928 (No. 3807), Part III — Wrongs (Contributory Negligence) Act 1951 (No. 5594), sec. 3.

IN RE ARMSTRONG AND STATE RIVERS COMMISSION (No. 2)VLR 288

SHOLL, J. delivered with his awards the following written reasons·17 Apr 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

WaterCompensation for flooding — Arbitration — Extinguishment or reduction of claim — Water Act 1928 (No. 3801), sec. 263.

KRANZ v. RILEY DODDS AUSTRALIA LTD.VLR 296

FULL COURT (Lowe, O’Bryan and Dean JJ.).·23 Mar 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

DamagesAmount — Interference by appellate Court.

HENRY HASKIN & CO. PTY. LTD v. HOOKEVLR 300

HUDSON, J. read the following judgment·4 Mar 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeTrial of action — Allegation by plaintiff's counsel in opening case that plaintiff's claim based on felony — Whether action should be stayed.

COX v. EDBROOKEVLR 305

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·9 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

HairdressersPower to make regulations "prescribing standard of hygiene sanitation and safety to be observed in premises where hairdressing is practised" — Whether "hairdressing" confined to hairdressing operations "for fee reward salary wages or other remuneration or consideration by whomsoever paid or payable" — Hairdressers Registration Act 1936 (No. 4396), secs. 2, 22.

WOX v. CLUB MOTOR INSURANCE AGENCY PTY. LTD.VLR 308

LOWE, J., in the course of his charge to the jury, said·30 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Motor carLiability incurred by owner or driver for death or bodily injury — Action against insurer — Where owner or driver cannot be found — After "strict inquiry and search" — Meaning of words — Motor Car Act 1951 (No. 5616), sec. 46 (1).

COOK v. ROWEVLR 309

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·26 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantPartnership between lessees — Lease a partnership asset — Partnership dissolved — One former partner remaining on in demised premises — Partnership assets assigned to him by deed of dissolution — Whether assignment a ground for notice to quit — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), sec. 37 (5) (n).

McMAHON v. CARTERVLR 315

DEAN, J., read the following judgment·5 Mar 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marketing of primary productsEgg pulp — Regulation relating to production of egg pulp — Whether regulation authorized by power to regulate marketing — Marketing of Primary Products Act 1935 (No. 4337), sec. 43 — Marketing of Primary Products (Validation) Act 1939 (No. 4658), sec. 2 — Egg and Egg Pulp Marketing Board Regulations, reg. 46.

PENNELL v. O’CALLAGHANVLR 320

BARRY, J. read the following judgment·7 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

NegligenceMotor collision — Plaintiff passenger in car colliding with truck — Plaintiff joint owner of car — Driving of car as plaintiff's agent — Finding by jury of negligence against both drivers — Assessment of plaintiff's damages at 6,500l. — Finding of jury that just and equitable that, having regard to car driver's responsibility for damages, damages payable by truck driver should be reduced by 1,950l. — Intention of jury that car driver should be liable for 1,950l. and truck driver liable for 4,550l. — Form of judgment — Costs — Wrongs (Tortfeasors) Act 1949 (No. 5382), sec. 2 (2) — Wrongs (Contributory Negligence) Act 1951 (No. 5594), sec. 3 (1), (6).

WOORINEN FRUITGROWERS CO-OPERATIVE LTD. v. CAMPBELLVLR 325

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy and O’Bryan JJ. and Hudson A.-J.)·17 Nov 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Workers' CompensationPower of Board to make determination — "With respect to" total liability of employer for weekly payments — May be unlimited as to amount — If maximum to liability is fixed, must be a definite sum — Workers' Compensation Act 1951 (No. 4601), sec. 9 (2), clause 1(1)(b)(i), (ii), (iii).

PAUL v. PAULVLR 331

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·2 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceLunacy or unsoundness of mind — Hospital for the insane — Meaning of "detained in any hospital for the insane" — Temporary patient — Voluntary patient — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), sec. 75 (f) — Mental Hygiene Act 1933 (No. 4157), Schedule, para. 4 — Marriage (Divorce) Act 1933 (No. 4210), sec. 3 — Mental Hygiene Act 1928 (No. 3721), secs. 3, 105 (1).

IN RE R., AN INFIRM PERSONVLR 334

LOWE, J.·6 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Public TrusteeInfirm person — Application for appointment of guardian — What matters must be proved — Public Trustee Act 1939 (No. 4654), sec. 49.

FRIEDMAN v. KEMP’S NURSERIES LTD.VLR 336

O’BRYAN, J.·4 Nov 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Service and execution of processService of writ on defendant outside jurisdiction of Supreme Court — Breach of contract — Motion to set aside service of writ and to stay proceedings — On ground that any contract or breach occurred outside jurisdiction of Court — Appropriate order on motion — Service and Execution of Process Act 1901-1953, secs. 4, 11, 13.

LECKIE v. HARRISVLR 341

DEAN, J.·10 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Gas regulationJustices — Power to award damages in addition to fine — Gas Regulation Act 1933 (No. 4142), secs. 3 (2), 29 (1), 30 (b) — Gas and Fuel Corporation Act 1950 (No. 5507), sec. 11 (2)(d).

IN RE AUSTRALASIAN ASIATIC TRADING & ENGINEERING CO. PTY. LTD.VLR 344

MARTIN, J.·2 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

CompaniesInvestigation of company's affairs — Inspector appointed — Power of inspector to require officers and agents of company to answer questions — Whether former director may be compelled to answer — Companies Act 1938 (No. 4602), sec. 136.

BARKOWSKY v. BARKOWSKYVLR 346

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·8 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Husband and wifeMaintenance — Order for maintenance of wife — Subsequent decree for dissolution of marriage granted to husband on ground of wife's desertion — Whether husband entitled to have maintenance order discharged — Maintenance Act 1928 (No. 3722), sec. 15 (12).

BURTON v. MELBOURNE HARBOR TRUST COMMISSIONERSVLR 353

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Sholl and Smith JJ.).·20 Oct 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

NegligenceDangerous premises — Goods stacked negligently in shed on wharf — Wharf and shed allotted by Harbor Trust to shipowners for purpose of discharging goods from ship — Goods unloaded and stacked in shed by stevedoring company and thereby delivered to shipowners as wharfingers licensed for goods by Harbor Trust — Plaintiff injured while taking delivery of goods from shed on behalf of consignee — Bale falling on plaintiff from pile of negligently stacked bales — Action by plaintiff against Harbor Trust, shipping company and stevedoring company — Whether Harbor Trust "occupier" of shed — Invitee — Evidence of continuing dangerous condition — Whether shipowners liable under principles established in Donoghue v. Stevenson — Verdict and judgment against all three defendants — Successful appeal by shipowners, verdict set aside and order for new trial — Whether verdicts against other two defendants should also be set aside — Joint or concurrent tortfeasors.

SAARINEN v. CLAYVLR 392

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·13 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

NegligenceMotor car collision — Costs — Payment into Court — Payment in of more than amount recovered by plaintiff by reason of plaintiff's contributory negligence reducing damages — Trial prolonged by joinder by defendant of third party — Principles applicable to awarding of costs — Rules of Supreme Court 1951, Order XXII, rr. 1-6 — Wrongs (Contributory Negligence) Act 1951 (No. 5594).

WALTER v. NELMSVLR 398

SHOLL, J. read a judgment in which, after dealing with other matters, he said·30 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and purchaserContract for sale of business — Carried on in rented premises — Conditional on vendor surrendering lease and landlord granting new lease to purchaser — No obligation on vendor to procure grant of new lease.

R. v. BROWNVLR 403

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Dean and Smith JJ.).·4 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawSentence — Power to suspend sentence — Four sentences imposed at same time — Sentences totalling more than three years in all — Sentences suspended — Validity of suspension — Crimes Act 1928 (No. 3664), Sec. 532.

WARNER v. WOMEN’S HOSPITALVLR 410

SHOLL, J.·5 Mar 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidenceAction against hospital — Records of admission, treatment and discharge of patients — Whether admissible — Legal professional privilege — What constitutes prospective litigation — Privilege from disclosure — Objection may not be taken upon tender of evidence — Where document tendered already disclosed — Statement of medical opinion — Whether admissible as "statement" — Evidence Act 1946 (No. 5183), sec. 3.

MAYNARD v. SILCOCKVLR 423

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·6 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantPrescribed premises — Notice to quit — Ground of notice — Premises reasonably required by lessors for occupation by themselves and specified dependants — Whether notice valid — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), sec. 37 (5) (g) (i).

BAPTIST v. SCOTTVLR 431

MARTIN, J.·26 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

JusticesPower to adjourn during the hearing — Determination of a case — Meaning — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), secs. 72, 89 (6).

IN RE LESSERVLR 435

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Barry and Dean JJ.).·17 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

TrusteesIncome for maintenance, education and benefit of infant beneficiaries — Excessive accumulation of income — Meaning of accumulation of income "during a minority"; "under the general law" — Effect of statutory provisions on excessive accumulations of income and upon their operation upon a will — "Prior interest" in accumulated income — Court's inherent jurisdiction to apply infants' property for their benefit and make provision for their maintenance out of income — Trustee Act 1928 (No. 3792), secs. 3, 31 — Property Law Act 1928 (No. 3754), secs. 164, 165 — Wills Act 1928 (No. 3803), sec. 34.

HEALY v. SOUTHERN MILK TRANSPORT PTY. LTD.VLR 448

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·25 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantJurisdiction of Court of Petty Sessions — Agreement for a lease — Specific performance — Option of renewal — Effect of exercise of option at a time when lessee in breach of obligations under the lease — Breaches remedied before date of expiration of the lease — Whether valid exercise of the option — Estoppel — Landlord and Tenant Act 1928 (No. 3710), sec. 72 — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 28, 32 (4), 42, 45, 78 — Property Law Act (No. 3754), sec. 146 — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), secs. 65, 69 — Instruments Act 1928 (No. 3706), secs. 128, 129 — Supreme Court Act 1928 (No. 3783), sec. 61 (2).

R. v. FAHEYVLR 460

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Smith and Hudson JJ.).·18 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawSentence — Declaration as habitual criminal — Crimes Act 1928 (No. 3664), sec. 514.

R. v. CITY OF MOORABBINVLR 465

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·18 Mar 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Local governmentBy-law made pursuant to regulations — Regulations subsequently amended — Whether by-law rendered invalid — Adoption by council of planning scheme — In which residential zone defined — Exemption in case of lands, based on past use and past ownership — Scheme not invalidated — "Premises" — Meaning of — Local Government Act 1946 (No. 5203), Part XLIX; sec. 197 (7); Town and Country Planning Act 1944 (No. 5043), secs. 7 et seq.; Town and Country Planning Act 1948 (No. 5273); sec. 5.

TAYLOR v. MARMARASVLR 476

O’BRYAN, J. read the following judgment·30 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantApplication for possession — Rights of person entitled to equitable charge upon the property to be heard — Whether an "owner" — Whether a "party aggrieved" — Service of notice of application — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 73 (3) (a), (b), 75 (5) (b) — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), secs. 66, 150, 155 — Acts Interpretation Act 1928 (No. 3630), sec. 24.

R. v. CZERWINSKIVLR 483

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, Dean and Smith JJ.).·4 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Criminal lawEvidence — Statement by accused — Accused of foreign extraction not interrogated in presence of interpreter — Whether answers admissible in evidence — Direction to jury where accused's statement is admitted in evidence as a voluntary statement.

IN RE WILKINSONVLR 486

GAVAN DUFFY, J. read the following judgment·15 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

TrustsPower of trustees — Preferential right to subscribe for share issues — Proceeds of sale of rights and of shares purchased with such rights — Capital or income — Whether trustees authorised to subscribe for such share issues — Bonus Shares — Whether capital or income.

IN RE CRABTREEVLR 492

HERRING, C.J. read the following judgment·10 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

WillConstruction — Use of residence by unmarried daughters while unmarried — Income payable to unmarried daughters — Codicil giving married daughters same rights as unmarried daughters — Period of distribution of estate — Condition of cesser of interest in estate on ceasing to reside, in home of sisters — Condition subsequent — Whether void for uncertainty — Issue — Meaning of — Restricted to children — Requirement that children survive period of distribution in order to take — Accrued shares — Who entitled to take.

IN RE K. L. TRACTORS LTD.VLR 505

O’BRYAN J. read the following judgment·6 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

CompaniesWinding-up by the Court — Company having right of set-off against debt — Creditor competent to present petition — Company's omission to pay because bon fide disputes indebtedness — Not a "neglect to pay" statutory demand — Dispute must be based on substantial ground — Competent for winding-up Court to decide whether a substantial ground — Prim facie right of creditor to winding-up order — Discretion in Court to refuse order — When Court will exercise in favour of company — Whether counter-claim an answer to petition — Companies Act 1938 (No. 4602), secs. 166 (1) (e), 167 (a).

SHEPHERD v. SHEPHERDVLR 514

SHOLL, J.·22 Sept 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceDefended petition and counter-petition — Evidence — Power of Court to call evidence in order to investigate allegations made in pleadings — Form of order — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), sec. 80.

EvidenceStatement made by person in document and tending to establish admissible fact — "Person interested" — "At a time when proceedings were pending or anticipated" — Evidence Act 1946 (No. 5183), sec. 3 (1), (3).

GILLARD v. GAMEVLR 525

SHOLL, J. read a judgment [in which he dealt with certain aspects of the evidence and continued:]·15 Dec 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

StampsBill of exchange — Promissory note — Document under seal containing acknowledgment of receipt of loan, undertaking to repay upon written demand, undertaking that acknowledgment should bind promisor's executors and that promisor if called upon by promisee would execute further documents to secure repayment of amount lent or such sum as should then be owing by promisor to promisee — Whether promissory note — Whether document constituted account stated — Whether statutory definitions of "bill of exchange" and "bill of exchange payable on demand" include promissory notes — Whether insufficiently stamped promissory note may be stamped upon presentation for payment — Whether bon fide holder for value of irregularly stamped promissory note may recover in action on note upon affixing thereto proper adhesive stamp at trial of action — Stamps Act 1946 (No. 5204), secs. 41, 46, 47, 48.

HARNETT v. HARNETTVLR 533

BARRY, J. read the following judgment·29 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

InfantCustody — Contest between father and mother — Welfare of child — Child of tender years — Desirability of custody by mother — Exercise of discretion — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), secs. 105, 136, 145.

HENDRY v. FISHERVLR 539

HERRING C.J.·4 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

JusticesAppeal to Court of General Sessions — Application to General Sessions to state case for Supreme Court — Made some days after appeal allowed but while same Chairman still sitting — Application not out of time — Justices Act 1929 (No. 3708), sec. 147.

AnimalsDogs — May be destroyed if found in field, paddock, yard or other place enclosed by a fence — In which sheep, cattle or poultry confined — Provision inapplicable where killing takes place in building — Dog Act 1928 (No. 3667), sec. 19.

BROADHURST v. PAULVLR 541

HERRING C.J.·29 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Transport regulationDriving commercial goods vehicle — Without statutory period of rest — Whether whole period of driving without requisite rest period must take place in Victoria — Permitting employee to drive without proper period of rest — Abstaining from taking reasonable steps to prevent employee from driving without rest — Commission of offence — Transport Regulation Act 1933 (No. 4198), sec. 39 (1) (c).

IN RE DICKVLR 546

MARTIN J. read the following judgment·20 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Settled landFreehold property — Trust to permit residence therein for life — Whether beneficiary a tenant for life — Settled Land Act 1928 (No. 3771), sec. 12.

VARELLA v. MARSICOVETEREVLR 550

HERRING C.J.·30 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantLease — Licence — Whether tenant or lodger.

IN RE BERRYVLR 557

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·29 July 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Administration and probatePayment of legacies and annuities — Where lapsed share of residue — Whether payment to be made out of lapsed share or general residuary estate — Intestacy arising only after death of life tenant — Administration and Probate Act 1928 (No. 3632), secs. 4, 33, 34.

NAISMITH v. SMITHVLR 567

HUDSON, J. read the following judgment·11 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and purchaserUncompleted contract for sale of land — Contract by purchaser for sale to third party of portion of land included in original contract — Payment in full by third party of purchase price for such portion — Failure of original purchaser to pay his vendor — Disappearance of purchaser — Rights as between original vendor and third party to title of whole land.

HALL v. WILSONVLR 576

O’BRYAN, J. read the following judgment·30 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeCosts — Action for damages for negligence — Two defendants — Alleged breaches of different duties of care owed by each defendant to plaintiff — Plaintiff successful against one defendant only — Whether unsuccessful defendant should pay successful defendant's costs.

ABBOTT v. ABBOTTVLR 578

SHOLL, J. read the following judgment·2 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorcePractice — Discovery — Application for — Cause or matter other than one commenced by writ of summons — Whether order for discovery may be made on ex parte application — Whether summons necessary — Rules of Supreme Court, Order XXXI, r. 12.

MUSSELL v. MUSSELLVLR 581

DEAN, J. read the following judgment·23 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceJudicial separation — Power of Court to set aside decree of judical separation and discharge alimony order — On resumption of cohabitation — What amounts to resumption of cohabitation.

SHARPE v. YOUNGVLR 586

HERRING, C.J.·30 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantRecovery of possession of premises — On ground premises required by lessors — Power in Court to effect division of premises between lessors and tenant — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 45 (1), 46 (a) (ii).

COOK v. LEONARDVLR 591

SHOLL, J.·11 Feb 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidencePrivilege — Solicitor and client — Preparation of document — Whether solicitor may be questioned as to the person for whom he was acting when he prepared the document.

DAVEY v. BARROWVLR 593

HERRING, C.J. read the following judgment·13 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

JusticesCosts — Information — Dismissal — Discretion to refuse costs to successful defendant — Justices Act 1928 (No. 3708), sec. 102.

ATKINSON v. HANELVLR 596

SMITH, J. read the following judgment·30 Apr 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Transport regulationLicence of commercial vehicle for special purposes — Variation of licence by issue of permit — Information — Defendant charged with operating vehicle otherwise than in accordance with the conditions of the licence issued — Onus of proving that licence not varied by permit — Transport Regulation Act 1933 (No. 4198), secs. 32, 46.

DOWNIE v. TAYLORVLR 603

SHOLL, J.·8 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantContracts deemed to be leases by statute — For purposes of prior Act — Provision inoperative to apply relevant Parts of prior Act to certain premises — Owner living on premises — Rebuttal of presumption that person using rooms and paying rent a lodger — Prices regulation — Meaning of "annoyance" — Landlord and Tenant Act 1953 (No. 5760), secs. 2 (a), 4 (1) — Prices Regulation Act 1948 (No. 5310), sec. 35 (1) (b) (ii) — Prices Regulation Act 1949 (No. 5429), sec. 3.

WILL v. WILLVLR 614

FULL COURT (Martin, Dean and Smith JJ.).·23 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

MaintenanceWife leaving husband without just cause or excuse — No offer to return to matrimonial home — Wife without means of support — Husband not prepared to have wife back — Whether wife entitled to maintenance from husband — Maintenance Act 1928 (No. 3722), secs. 4 (a), 6 (1).

THOMSON v. CROSSVLR 635

SHOLL, J. read the following judgment·24 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

JusticesOrder to review — Conflicting affidavits — Practice of preferring answering affidavit — May be departed from in proper case.

Landlord and tenantConcurrent lease of flat — Whether extended to garage leased with flat by freeholder to tenant — Notice to quit given by concurrent lessee — Whether extended to garage — Original lease by freeholder to tenant not in writing — Whether, if reversion severed, assignee of part thereof competent to give valid notice to quit — Estoppel — Payment of rent for flat and garage — Whether tenant estopped from relying on insufficiency of concurrent lease to cover garage — Property Law Act 1928 (No. 3754), Division 5.

IN RE UNIVERSAL GUARANTEE PTY. LIMITEDVLR 650

LOWE, J. read the following judgment·2 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

SolicitorUnqualified person — Preparation for reward of instrument relating to personal property — Hire-purchase company preparing for fee form of transfer of hirer's interest in hired chattel — Legal Profession Practice Act 1941 (No. 4418), sec. 48.

CITY OF CAMBERWELL v. REEDVLR 653

SHOLL, J.·26 May 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Local governmentScheme of street construction — Objection thereto — Reference of objection to Court of Petty Sessions — Objector to be given notice thereof — Notice to be personally served — Court to fix time and place for hearing and direct who shall effect service of notice — Local Government Act 1946 (No. 5203), sec. 578.

TAYLOR v. McQUEEN AND WILLIAMSONVLR 661

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy, O’Bryan and Hudson JJ.).·26 Feb 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Workers' compensation"Disease" — Defined as including aggravation, acceleration or recurrence of pre-existing disease — Compensation for "disease due to nature of any employment" — "Disease of such a nature as to be contracted by a gradual process" — Whether definition applicable — Inconsistency with context or subject-matter — Atheroma — Worker subject to atheromatous condition before commencing last employment before death — Whether employer liable in respect of an industrial disease — Workers' Compensation Act 1951 (No. 5601), secs. 3, 12 (1) (b), 14.

TILLEY v. PHILLIPSVLR 682

HUDSON, J. read the following judgment·22 June 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantLicence — Construction — Licence created by implication — Effect — Landlord and Tenant Act 1953 (No. 5760), sec. 4 (1).

IN RE A SOLICITORVLR 687

HERRING, C.J. read the following judgment·5 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

SolicitorRefusal of application for practising certificate — Deficiences in trust account caused through lax office administration over several years — No dishonesty of applicant — Whether relief against refusal should be granted by Court — Nature of appeal to Court — Legal Profession Practice Act 1936 (No. 4418), secs. 3, 4; Legal Profession Practice Act 1946 (No. 5182), secs. 28, 34, 36, 39, 42, 45; Solicitors (Audit and Practising Certificates) Rules 1947, rule 38.

FODE v. TAYLORVLR 696

MARTIN, J.·25 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Landlord and tenantApplication for possession — Notice to quit — On ground that premises being a dwelling-house are reasonably required by one of two lessors — Concession granted by statute to "lessor" — Not applicable unless premises required by all lessors — Landlord and Tenant Act 1948 (No. 5264), secs. 37, 45; Landlord and Tenant Act 1953 (No. 5760), sec. 16 (2).

EWART v. FOXVLR 699

FULL COURT (Gavan Duffy and O’Bryan JJ. and Hudson A.-J.).·10 Nov 1953·Supreme Court of Victoria

LicensingOffences — Whether doctrine of marital coercion applicable — Licensing Act 1928 (No. 3717), sec. 161.

X v. YVLR 708

SHOLL J.·19 July 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidenceOf physician or surgeon — Whether admissible without consent of patient — Meaning of "patient" — Prohibition against disclosure of information unless sanity of patient in dispute — When "sanity" in dispute — Opinion based on information excluded — Whether section positively prohibits evidence or merely enables privilege to be claimed — Evidence Act 1928 (No. 3674), sec. 28.

X v. Y (No. 2)VLR 715

SHOLL J.·30 July 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidenceRight of Judge to ask questions of witness — To test credit — Where Judge suspects recent invention — Right to ask witness to produce notes alleged to have been handed solicitor before trial.

X v. Y (No. 3)VLR 720

SHOLL J.·4 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeCosts — Ward of Court — Action for administration of infant's property — Summonses concerning guardianship and education — Mother a party — Whether interlocutory order for her costs should be made — Either against husband (next friend) or out of infant's settled fund — Marriage Act 1928 (No. 3726), sec. 145.

ARMSTEAD v. ARMSTEADVLR 733

FULL COURT (Herring C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·3 Sept 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

DivorceDomicil — Acquisition of domicil of choice while member of armed services.

CLARKSON v. MADDENVLR 738

SHOLL, J. read the following judgment·6 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marketing of primary productsInterstate trade and commerce — Potatoes — Sale in Victoria by importer from another State of potatoes originally intended by him for use as seed on his farm — Whether sale is in the course of trade, commerce or intercourse between the States or within protection of sec. 92 of Commonwealth Constitution — Offence — Sale of potatoes other than to marketing board — Exculpatory provisions — Whether onus on defendant to establish or on informant to negative applicability — "Producer" — "Obtained" — Whether extends to obtaining of commodity from another person, by purchase or otherwise, in its complete state — Whether prohibition of sale of commodity by producer other than to marketing board extends to portion of commodity so sold but not actually produced by producer — Marketing of Primary Products Act 1935 (No. 4337), secs. 4, 19 (c).

SWANN v. SWANNVLR 750

SMITH, J.·18 Aug 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

EvidenceAdmissibility — Divorce — Adultery — Claim for damages — Evidence of complaints by wife — Concerning husband's treatment of her — Evidence admissible to show type of wife she was — As affecting quantum of damages.

AUSTRALASIAN ASIATIC TRADING & ENGINEERING CO. PTY. LTD. v. FORSYTH-GRANTVLR 752

GAVAN DUFFY, J.·3 Sept 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeOrder empowering plaintiff to enter final judgment — Application to set aside — On ground that it was a "judgment by default" — Rule not applicable — Rules of the Supreme Court, O. XIV; O. XXVII, r. 15.

CLUB MOTOR INSURANCE AGENCY PTY. LTD. v. SWANNVLR 754

FULL COURT (Herring C.J., Barry and Dean JJ.).·22 Sept 1954·Supreme Court of Victoria

Motor carCollision — Action for personal injuries sustained by plaintiff — Counter-claim for personal injuries sustained by defendant in same collision — Authorized insurer — Extent of right of authorized insurer of plaintiff to take over conduct and control of action on behalf of plaintiff — Motor Car Act 1951 (No. 5616), sec. 55.

InsuranceCompulsory third party — Right of insurer to conduct and control action for personal injuries already commenced by plaintiff on own behalf.