Unlimited digital access from $45/mo. Print subscriptions with bound volumes available.Shop Now

Browse

View Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports by volume number

17 VLR(144 results)

Cases reported in this volume of the Victorian Reports

IN RE HOLLAND17 VLR 1

A’BECKETT, J.·2 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice probateMoneys collected by trustees — Decease of trustees — Administration d.b.n.

DAVEY v. BULLOCK17 VLR 3

HODGES, J.·3 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Insolvency Statute 1871" (No. 379), s. 71Fraudulent preference — Bona fides of creditor.

SANDER v. THE QUEEN17 VLR 8

HOOD, J.·3 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Land Act 1884" (No. 812), ss. 27 (8), (10), (13); 29, 68Pastoral lease — Resumption of land by Crown — Order in Council — Selection — Payment of fees on application for selection — Petition — "Crown Remedies and Liabilities Act 1890."

IN RE HOLLAND17 VLR 18

A’BECKETT, J.·2 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice probateMoneys collected by trustees — Decease of trustees — Administration d.b.n.

THE QUEEN v. McLELLAN17 VLR 19

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·10 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"Land Tax Act 1890," ss. 3, 4, 6, 7, 10, 15Classification — Liability to pay tax on landed estate prior to classification.

MUNTZ v. ELKINGTON17 VLR 23

WEBB, J.·12 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884," Order XIV., r. 1 — Application for final judgment — Affidavit in support.

McNAMARA v. CLARTON17 VLR 24

WEBB, J.·16 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of Supreme Court 1884," Order XIV., r. 1Defect in previous application subsequently cured.

HUMPHREYS v. COLDWELL17 VLR 25

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·17 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Landlord and Tenant Statute 1864" (No. 192), ss. 90, 91, 96, 100Landlord and tenant — Warrant of possession — Action of trespass — Demand of possession — Right to possession.

BOURCHIER v. MITCHELL17 VLR 27

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·19 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

HighwayTravelling sheep — Owner of fenced land adjoining highway — Trespass by sheep — Impounding — Primary judge deciding on point not raised — Appeal.

McMILLAN v. McMILLAN17 VLR 33

HODGES, J.·23 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Trustee and cestui que trustSolicitor allowed by trustee to receive trust funds — Misapplication by solicitor — Liability of trustee — Negligence of cestui que trust — Negligence.

SERVICE v. COOTE17 VLR 40

WEBB, J.·24 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order XXXI., r. 11 — Interrogatories — Further answers — Infringement of trade mark.

KRAITZER v. JENKINS17 VLR 42

WEBB, J.·24 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order XXXI., r.1 — Interrogatories — Application for leave to administer interrogatories before defence — Payment of money into Court with denial of liability.

CAIRNS v. WALSH17 VLR 44

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., and WEBB, J.·13 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Garnishee order nisiOrder nisi for sequestration.

FITZGERALD v. BUTTON17 VLR 52

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·20 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Landlord and tenantLease by tenant for life terminating on his death — Continuance in possession by tenant — Receipt of rent by remainderman — Creation of tenancy — Question of fact.

ORMOND v. FINLAY17 VLR 55

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·27 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Originating summonsWill, construction of — Codicil — Residuary legatees — Charitable institutions — Proportion of shares in residuary estate — Legacy.

CURWEN v. YAN YEAN LAND COMPANY LIMITED17 VLR 64

WEBB, J.·10 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and purchaserLand company — Shareholder — Promoter of company — Fraudulent concealment — Concealment of vendor — Form of relief.

BENJAMIN v. SANDERS17 VLR 68

WEBB, J.·11 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

WillConstruction of — Trustee — Real estate — Direction to sell within limited period — Directory not mandatory — Jurisdiction of Court — Postponement of sale.

In the Matter of REAL PROPERTY ACT 189017 VLR 71

A’BECKETT, J.·24 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Settled estatesThe Real Property Act 1890 (No. 1136), ss. 87, 89 — Sale of settled estates — Payment of proceeds of sale to trustees — Practice.

IN THE MATTER OF THE TRANSFER OF LAND ACT 189017 VLR 77

A’BECKETT, J.·24 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Transfer of Land Act 1890 (No. 1149)ss. 85, 86, 134 — Production of certificate of title — Custody of certificate of title by mortgagee — Mortgagor, default of.

REGINA v. HARE17 VLR 80

A’BECKETT, J.·23 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Justices of the PeaceJustices Act 1890, sec. 89, sub-sec. 2 — Power of magistrates to award costs.

IN RE TRANSFER OF LAND ACT 189017 VLR 82

A’BECKETT, J.·10 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Transfer of Land Act 1890, ss. 145, 209Mandamus on Registrar of Titles to compel registration.

IN RE HOPKINS17 VLR 85

A’BECKETT, J.·16 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

CostsBill of costs — Taxation — Solicitor and client — Substitution of bill of costs for one already delivered to client — Signature of bill.

IN RE DOBSON17 VLR 88

A’BECKETT, J.·16 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

CostsSolicitor and client — Bill of costs — Taxation — Substituted bill of costs.

MACKAY v. JELLIE17 VLR 91

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOLROYD, WEBB, and HODGES, JJ.·29 Sept 1890·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"Insolvency Statute 1871" (No. 379), ss. 37 (ii.) and 71Debtor hopelessly insolvent — Delivery of whole of property to creditor in consideration of past debt — Threat of action — Intent to defeat creditors — Fraudulent preference — Pressure.

IN RE JOHNSTON, DUNSTER & COMPANY17 VLR 100

A’BECKETT, J.·2 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Companies Act 1890 (No. 1074), s. 49Table A, r. 37 — Quorum — Company reduced to less than five members — Resolution for winding up — Supervision of Court.

JAMES v. GIBSON17 VLR 104

WEBB, J.·17 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Case reserved for Full CourtJurisdiction of Full Court — Entry up of judgment — Injunction continued until further order — Further order before judgment drawn up.

WORNE v. BERGER17 VLR 107

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order LIV., r. 24 — Order LVIII., r. 10 — Appeal from decision in chambers.

IN RE ANNAND17 VLR 108

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Transfer of Land Act 1890 (No. 1149), s. 145Practice — Proceedings to remove caveat — Costs.

LINDSAY v. L. STEVENSON & SONS LIMITED17 VLR 112

WEBB, J.·16 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

GuaranteeMisrepresentation — Deceit — Uberrimae fidei — Breach of guarantee — Damages.

IN RE HARRIES17 VLR 116

A’BECKETT, J.·12 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice probateJoint administrators.

GRAVES v. THE COUNTY ESTATES CO. LIMITED17 VLR 117

WEBB, J.·12 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Land tax"The Land Tax Act 1877" (No. 575) — Vendor of landed estate — Purchaser of allotment less than taxable area — Agreement to pay "rates and other out-goings" — Liability of purchaser for land tax.

IN RE TAYLOR17 VLR 121

A’BECKETT, J.·13 Mar 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Insolvency Act 1890 (No. 1102), ss. 37-38Petitioning creditor's debt — Promissory note not due — "Sum due."

JAMIESON v. RENWICK17 VLR 124

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·3 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

AgreementPromise to pay an annuity — On certain conditions — Consideration.

VAUGHAN v. SHIRE OF BENALLA17 VLR 129

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·13 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Land Act 1890, ss. 123, 124Grazing licensee — Right of, to maintain action for actual damage.

SHILLINGLAW v. ROBERTS17 VLR 136

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·10 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Poisons Act 1890, ss. 4 and 14Justices Act 1890, s. 204 — Sale of poison — Burden of proof that person selling comes within exceptions and exemptions in the Act — Order in writing.

YOUNG v. MOOK AH MENG17 VLR 140

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Instruments and Securities Statute 1864," ss. 63, 56Requisites to constitute document a bill of sale — Sale note with inventory of chattels.

BRADLEY & SON v. BERTOUMIEUX17 VLR 144

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·10 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

ContractContract relating to goods — Breach of contract — Delay — Refusal to perform — Inability to perform declared — Rescission.

MOWLING v. JUSTICES OF HAWTHORN17 VLR 150

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·13 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

HealthHealth Act 1890 (No. 1098), ss. 216 (1) and 222 — "House or premises" — Paddock — Suffering a nuisance — Knowledge of servant.

DANBY v. AUSTRALIAN FINANCIAL AGENCY AND GUARANTEE CO. LIMITED17 VLR 156

HODGES, J.·14 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order XXXI., r. 11 — Interrogatories as to documents after discovery.

JAMIESON v. SAMS17 VLR 159

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·14 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

ContractConstruction — Special contract — Master and seaman — Discharge — Notice of discharge — Unexpired notice — Desertion.

COLLINS v. FREEMAN17 VLR 166

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·15 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

County Court Act 1890 (No. 1078)Appeal by motion — Time for appealing — Extension of time — "Rule of the Supreme Court."

THE MAYOR, ETC., OF SOUTH MELBOURNE v. TAYLOR17 VLR 167

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·20 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Local Government Act 1890 (No. 1112), ss. 3, 257Recovery of rates — Owner, meaning of.

REGINA v. MORTON17 VLR 178

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·16 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

PracticeCriminal Law — Crimes Act 1890 (No. 1079) ss. 481, 482, 485, and 486 — Mandamus to compel chairman of General Sessions to reserve a point of law — Chairman of Court of General Sessions — Reservation of question of law at criminal trial.

FLORINS v. THE BANK OF VICTORIA LIMITED17 VLR 183

HODGES, J.·23 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticePleading — "Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order XIX., r. 4 — Pleading evidence — Order XXV., r. 4 — Claim disclosing no reasonable cause of action, application to strike out — Action to set aside judgment — Non-service of writ of summons.

RAY v. THE JUSTICES OF MELBOURNE AND WHITNEY17 VLR 186

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Justices Act 1890 (No. 1105), s. 128, sub-secs. (2), (9)Notice of appeal to Court of General Sessions — Service of notice of appeal — Waiver.

FOSTER v. O’CALLAGHAN17 VLR 193

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HODGES, and HOOD, JJ.·15 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Licensing Act 1885," ss. 56, 58Order for repairs by inspector — Service of on occupier and not on owner — Right of licensed occupier to recover from owner money expended.

WILLOUGHBY v. EASTERN PLATEAU PROPRIETARY GOLD MINING COMPANY17 VLR 196

HOOD, J.·6 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

County Court Act 1890 (No. 1078), s. 104Removal of County Court judgment to Supreme Court — Stay of proceedings — Appeal.

COANE & GRANT v. THE THOMAS BENT LAND COMPANY17 VLR 198

HOOD, J.·7 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court1884" — Order III., r. 6 — Order XIV., r. 1 — Specially indorsed writ — Claim for interest — The Supreme Court Act 1890, s. 224.

MACKIE v. CLOUGH17 VLR 201

HOOD, J.·11 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeSecurity for costs — No-liability company — Action by liquidator.

RICHARDS v. CADMAN17 VLR 203

WEBB, J.·13 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Transfer of Land Act 1890 (No. 1149), ss. 19, 55, and 139Judgment debtor — Fi. fa. — Lodgment for registration — Estate or interest of debtor not appearing in Register Book — Retention of fi. fa. in Titles Office — Mortgage — Lease from Crown — "Register Book" — Priority of registration.

GARDE v. MITCHELL17 VLR 209

HOOD, J.·18 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Injunction to restrain use of firm's nameEmployee of established firm setting up independent business — Intention to deceive.

ECKOLD v. CHILTERN VALLEY GOLD MINING CO.17 VLR 213

WEBB, J.·14 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Wrongs Act 1890 (No. 1160), ss. 14 & 15Liability for death wrongfully caused — Damages — Assessment by jury — Jurisdiction of judge.

McKELLAR v. ABBOTT17 VLR 215

WEBB, J.·15 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and purchaserSale of reversionary interest — Investigation of title — Balance of purchase-money — Debt.

CAMERON v. HUNTER17 VLR 217

WEBB, J.·9 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

WillRequest of money in specified banks — Deposits in building societies — "Money and valuables."

McKENZIE & COMPANY v. WALKER17 VLR 221

HODGES, J.·10 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884"Order XLV., r. 1 — Attachment of debts — Garnishee.

SHIRREFS v. JOHNSON17 VLR 225

HODGES, J.·28 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order LXIV., r. 14 — 9 & 10 Wm. III., c. 15 — The Supreme Court Act 1890 (No. 1142), s. 149 — Application to set aside award — Reasonable time — Reference to arbitration.

MANSFIELD v. MANSFIELD17 VLR 228

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·15 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

County Court Act 1890, ss. 68, 133Appeal — Rehearing by Supreme Court judge — Power of judge who rehears to award costs — Power of a County Court judge to grant injunction.

IN RE STREET & CO. LIMITED17 VLR 236

HODGES, J.·25 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Companies Act 1890, s. 93Winding up — Contributories — Shares described as fully paid up.

STEELE v. MAYOR OF ESSENDON17 VLR 239

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·30 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Local Government Act 1890, ss. 401, 405, 410, 449Negligence — Hole with insufficient fence.

LYONS v. LYONS17 VLR 243

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·24 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Marriage Act 1890 (No. 1166), ss. 43 and 50Order for maintenance — Order for security.

THE ESSENDON LAND, TRAMWAY, AND INVESTMENT CO. LIMITED v. UPTON17 VLR 248

WEBB, J.·6 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"The Companies Statute 1864" (No. 190)Company — Shares — Vendor and Purchaser — Execution of transfer to purchaser — Vendor's name still on share register — Statements by company's secretary, how far binding on company.

KING v. GRIMWOOD17 VLR 253

WEBB, J.·7 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and PurchaserContract of sale of land — Description of purchaser — "Grimwood & Co." — Instruments Act 1890 (No. 1103), s. 208 — Part performance — "Instruments Act 1890" (No. 1103), s. 209 — Retrospective enactment — Agent authorised in writing.

RATTEN v. DENBIGH17 VLR 259

WEBB, J.·21 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Administration actionWill construction — Costs — Fund out of which payable — Residuary devise.

ANDERSON v. WATSON17 VLR 263

WEBB, J.·28 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Instruments Act 1890 (No. 1103), ss. 133, 134, 135Bills of sale — Notice of intention to file — Residence and occupation of grantor — Registration — Residence of attesting witness — Affidavit of due execution — Variation between affidavit and bill of sale or notice of intention to file — Purchaser from grantee of bill of sale not duly filed.

MATHIESON v. THE MERCANTILE FINANCE AND AGENCY COMPANY LIMITED17 VLR 271

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"Transfer of Land Statute" (No. 301), ss. 42, 84, and 85Mortgage — Power of sale — Demand and notice — Notice of sale given prior to registration — Effect of registration.

STANLEY v. MOORE17 VLR 285

A’BECKETT, J.·3 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

CompanyAction by shareholder — Directors — Power to borrow money — Irregularity in exercise of power to borrow — Want of parties.

BICKFORD, SMITH & CO. v. MUSGROVE17 VLR 295

A’BECKETT, J.·3 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Customs and Excise Duties Act 1890 (No. 1082), Schedule 2Consolidation Acts 1890 — Acts Interpretation Act 1890 (No. 1058), Part II. — Alteration in previous law by Consolidating Act — Effect of alteration on matters occurring after Consolidating Act — Meaning of Consolidating Act doubtful, or difficulty — Duty on "Yarn."

McMECKAN v. AITKEN17 VLR 301

HODGES, J.·8 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeInterrogatories — Information of agents or servants.

PENGLASE v. THE BANK OF NEW ZEALAND17 VLR 308

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·19 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

DetinueLodgment of deeds to secure account — Ambiguity — Parol evidence — Joint account at bank — Admission of evidence.

IN RE SHEARS AND ALDER17 VLR 316

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·26 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Transfer of Land Act 1890 (No. 1, 149), ss. 209, 139Effect of lodging copy writ of fi. fa. on Registrar of Titles — Charge on the land — Registration of bona fide transfer within three months after lodging copy writ of fi. fa.

BROWN v. ROBERTSON17 VLR 324

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·25 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

ContractWant of authority to make contract — Principal and agent — Onus of proof.

ADCOCK v. ADCOCK17 VLR 328

WEBB, J.·3 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of Supreme Court 1884"Order XLV., r. 1 — Appendix B., No. 25, par. 4 — Garnishee — Form of affidavit.

GREEN v. THE QUEEN17 VLR 329

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·5 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Police Regulation Act 1890, ss. 20, 21, 35, 37Superannuation — Certificate signed by two members of a board consisting of three persons — Power of Governor in Council to superannuate a member of the police force.

REGINA v. McMAHON17 VLR 335

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·13 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Criminal LawBigamy — Mens rea — Honest belief on reasonable grounds of the invalidity of first marriage — Evidence — Statements made to prisoner by first wife — Evidence Act 1890 (No. 1088), s. 52 — Statement by prisoner to jury.

FOLEY v. EGAN17 VLR 340

A’BECKETT, J.·14 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Real Property Act 1890 (No. 1136), s. 23Tenant at will — Adverse possession — Statute of Limitations — Infancy — Trustee of infant in possession — Recovery of land.

MUSGROVE v. MITCHELL17 VLR 346

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·18 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Marine Act 1890 (No. 1165), s. 13Meaning of "Owner" — Service of notice on master of ship — Removal of wreck — Reasonable notice — Beneficial owner.

IN RE MYERS AND DAVIS17 VLR 351

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·18 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Insolvency Act 1890 (No. 1102), s. 35Voluntary sequestration of partnership firm on petition of one partner — Setting aside order for sequestration — Delay — Discretion of Court.

ROBERTS v. BRITISH BANK OF AUSTRALASIA17 VLR 355

WEBB, J.·18 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of Supreme Court 1884"Order XIV., r. 2 — Order LXX., r. 1.

HETHERINGTON v. DRISCOLL17 VLR 356

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·19 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

PracticeJudgment creditor — Attaching debt under garnishee order — Debts due or accruing — Order to review — Justices Act 1890 (No. 1105), ss. 117, 119, 141 — Right of judgment debtor to take out order to review — Person aggrieved.

SHILLINGLAW v. ROBERTS17 VLR 359

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., MOLESWORTH, and A’BECKETT, JJ.·21 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Poisons Act 1890 (No. 1125) s. 14Sale of poison — Entry in book — Order signed by purchaser.

MURPHY v. LEE17 VLR 364

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·21 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

By-law for regulating trafficLingering or loitering in street — Sale of commodity in street.

THE CITY NEWSPAPER COMPANY LIMITED v. THE EVENING STANDARD NEWSPAPER COMPANY17 VLR 368

WEBB, J.·24 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeInterrogatories — Inquiries as to information, or knowledge of servants or agents.

SUTTON v. SAUTTER17 VLR 371

WEBB, J.·24 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of Supreme Court 1884"Order XIV., r. 1 — Order LIV., r. 4* — Stay of proceedings — Setting aside judgment.

LAWLOR v. CRISP17 VLR 372

WEBB, J.·28 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884"Order XIX., r. 27 — Striking out — Slander — Pleading of defendant in same paragraph of defence.

O’CONNOR v. GILLESPIE17 VLR 374

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HODGES, and HOOD, JJ.·27 Apr 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Licensing Act 1890, ss. 128, 182Customs and Excise Duties Act 1890, Schedule 13 — Wine and spirit merchant selling liquor in quantity less than permitted by his license.

HACKER v. THE AUSTRALIAN PROPERTY AND FINANCE CO. LIMITED17 VLR 376

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·5 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Vendor and purchaserSale of land — Conditions of sale — Breach of contract — Unreasonable delay — Rescission — Consent of both parties — Damages.

TOMPSITT v. WILSON17 VLR 383

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·28 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

LibelWrongs Act 1890 (No. 1160), s. 5 — Questions for jury — Sufficiency of amount paid into Court by way of amends.

IN RE EBSWORTH17 VLR 391

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·20 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Contempt of CourtComments in newspaper on action pending new trial — Libel.

Per A'BECKETT and HOOD, JJ. (HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., dissentiente)

KILGARIFF v. DRISCOLL17 VLR 405

A’BECKETT, J.·14 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of Supreme Court 1884"Order LXV., r. 14 — Set-off — Solicitor's lien — Separate proceedings.

VICARY v. FOLEY17 VLR 407

HODGES, J.·11 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Action for non-delivery of scripMeasure of damages — Market value of shares — Time at which market value should be fixed.

IN RE BISHOP17 VLR 411

A’BECKETT, J.·15 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884"Order XXXI., r. 1 — Order LXVIII., r. 1 — Administration and Probate Act 1890, ss. 21, 44 — Probate — Caveat — Interrogatories.

IN RE KNIGHT17 VLR 413

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·30 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Supreme Court Act 1890, s. 20Probate — Executors resident out of jurisdiction — Power of court to require security from executors out of jurisdiction.

PERSSE v. DOCKERY17 VLR 420

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·30 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Malicious prosecutionWant of reasonable and probable cause — Defendant continuing prosecution after explanation by plaintiff.

WILLOUGHBY v. EASTERN PLATEAU PROPRIETARY CO.17 VLR 430

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·30 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

County Court Act 1890 (No. 1078), s. 133Appeal from order refusing new trial in County Court — Security to be lodged — Practice.

ROBERTSON v. BARRY17 VLR 434

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·29 May 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Sale of mineVendor and purchaser — Middleman — Fraudulent misrepresentation — Profit obtained by false representation.

BUTLER v. DUCKETT17 VLR 439

WEBB, J.·3 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Partner'sAssignment for benefit of creditors — Assignment executed by one partner — Agency — Implied authority of partner.

STEPHEN v. STEPHEN17 VLR 447

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·4 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Marriage and Matrimonial Causes Statute 1864" (No. 268), ss. 71, 79Alimony — Periodical sum ordered to be paid to a wife — Jurisdiction.

PERKINS v. DYSON17 VLR 451

WEBB, J.·9 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Will constructionGift of income to trustee for maintenance of mother and children — Children attaining majority — Marriage and foris-familiation of daughter — Discretion of trustee as to amount for maintenance.

IN RE PIGGOTT17 VLR 455

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·10 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Practice probateOrder nisi — Testamentary capacity — Primary judge admitting codicil to probate — Doubt of primary judge — Appeal on question of fact — Suspicious circumstances attending execution of codicil — Costs of caveatrix — Discretion of Court.

TONE v. BROLLY17 VLR 467

HOOD, J.·28 July 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Promissory noteAlleged payment to payee since deceased — Uncorroborated evidence of maker — Evidence of interested party — Admissibility of evidence — Weight of evidence — Statements by deceased person — Usual conduct of deceased.

FLORANCE v. HUTCHINSON17 VLR 471

A’BECKETT, J.·26 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Police Offences Act 1890 (No. 1126) s. 37Sweep or lottery — Sweep promoted in foreign country — Agreement between persons in Victoria to subscribe to — Legality of sweep in foreign country — Action to recover share of the winnings.

SPALDING v. BAILEY17 VLR 478

HODGES, J.·1 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

InsolvencyAct 5 Vic., No. 17, ss. 31 & 97 — Foreign insolvency — Discharge of debt — Prohibition of action against insolvent — Lex loci — Lex fori.

DANBY v. THE AUSTRALIAN FINANCIAL AGENCY AND GUARANTEE COMPANY LIMITED17 VLR 481

HODGES, J.·1 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Bill of saleConsideration — Collateral agreement — Instruments Act 1890 (No. 1103), ss. 134-5 and 146 — Condition.

STANLEY v. MOORE17 VLR 491

WEBB, J.·4 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Plaintiff suing in form pauperisCosts — Costs against pauper.

MACKIE v. CLOUGH17 VLR 493

WEBB, J.·4 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Companies Act 1890 (No. 1074), s. 236No liability company — Directors — Dividend payable out of capital — Liability of directors.

GUEST v. WATSON17 VLR 497

WEBB, J.·4 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Instruments Act 1890 (No. 1103) s. 209Sale of land — Rectification of written instrument — Specific performance of rectified instrument — Parol variation — Part performance.

SWEETNAM v. JACOBS17 VLR 501

A’BECKETT, J.·14 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884"Order XXVIII., r. 6 — Amendment — Unexplained delay in application for.

KIM v. McLELLAN17 VLR 503

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J.·2 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeCounty Court Act 1890 (No. 1078), s. 51 — Application to remit case to County Court — Visible means of paying costs — Affidavit in support of application.

SHEPHERD v. PENGLASE17 VLR 506

A’BECKETT, J.·7 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884" — Order XXXVI., rr. 39, 42 — Order XLII., r. 2* — Party entitled to judgment — Separate judgments in same action.

McVITTY v. CROWLEY17 VLR 508

A’BECKETT, J.·23 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"Rules of the Supreme Court 1884"Order LVII., r. 7 — Order LXV., r. 27 (41) — Interpleader issue — Costs where special order made.

IN RE ROYAL LAND COMPANY LIMITED17 VLR 510

A’BECKETT, J.·21 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Companies Act 1890, ss. 128, 129Voluntary winding up — Setting aside return of liquidator.

IN RE HOLLAND17 VLR 513

A’BECKETT, J.·2 Feb 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Practice probateMoneys collected by trustees — Decease of trustees — Administration d.b.n.

ANDREW & SON v. BARKER17 VLR 514

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·29 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Bill of saleNonsuit — Justices Act 1890 (No. 1105), s. 98 — Interpleader — Appeal from order — Bill of sale — After acquired goods ejusdem generis with goods enumerated in schedule — Schedule to bill of sale — Articles used in connection with business.

BALLANTYNE v. THE MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK17 VLR 520

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, MOLESWORTH, and HOOD, JJ.·9 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Life assuranceWarranty not to die by one's own act — Suicide — Untrue statement in application — Negligence of agent — Estoppel.

THE MOUNTAIN HOMES LAND INVESTMENT CO. LIMITED v. MARSHALL17 VLR 545

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HODGES, WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·9 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Companies Statute 1864" (No. 190)Memorandum of association — Objects for which company formed — Contract ultra vires of the directors — Illegality — Action on a void contract.

CARSLAKE v. PRESIDENT, ETC., OF THE SHIRE OF CAULFIELD17 VLR 560

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, HODGES, HOOD, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·30 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"Local Government Act 1874" (No. 506), ss. 276 and 384Construction of road — Side drains — Natural watercourse across road — Concentrating water into natural watercourse — Damage to adjoining lands.

ADKINS v. KILPATRICK17 VLR 603

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·11 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Health Act 1890 (No. 1098), s. 234Notice to form, etc., street — Plan endorsed.

DOBSON v. SHIRE OF FERNTREE GULLY17 VLR 606

WEBB, J.·7 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Local Government Act 1890 (No. 1112)Shire council — Misfeasance — Action against council — Plaintiff alleging no interest — Amendment.

TRUSTEES, EXECUTORS, AND AGENCY CO. LIMITED v. FINN17 VLR 609

WEBB, J.·7 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Partition Act 1890 (No. 1190) ss. 3, 4, and 5Tenants in common — Action for sale by one — Request by other for order for valuation and purchase — Purchase of share of party desiring sale.

SHAW v. HYETT17 VLR 612

HODGES, J.·19 Nov 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Uncertificated insolventDebts contracted after sequestration with knowledge of trustee and creditors — Priority of subsequent creditors.

THE AUSTRALASIAN MORTGAGE AND FINANCE CO. LIMITED v. GUTHRIDGE17 VLR 622

HOOD, J.·4 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Stamps Act 1890 (No. 1140), ss. 68, 76, 77, 87Promissory note — Duly cancelled stamp — Presumption in favour of bon fide holder — Cancellation of duty stamp.

DISMORR v. GEORGE17 VLR 626

WEBB, J.·7 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

LeaseAssignees of lease — Privity of contract — Mortgage — Option of purchase in mortgagee — Covenant clogging equity of redemption.

BLASHKI v. SMITH17 VLR 634

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HOOD, and A’BECKETT, JJ.·20 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

LibelWords necessarily libellous — Finding of jury where the presiding judge leaves it to the jury to say whether certain words are libellous or not.

REGINA v. TEEHAN17 VLR 640

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., HODGES, and HOOD, JJ.·21 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Marriage Act 1890 (No. 1166), s. 43Jurisdiction of justices in court of petty sessions — Order for maintenance of deserted child.

BARKER v. BREMNER17 VLR 643

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·30 Nov 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Attachment of moneys found upon prisoner before convictionMoney in possession of police — Garnishee.

IN RE THE MIDAS EXTENDED GOLD MINING CO.17 VLR 647

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·1 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Mines Act 1890 (No. 1120), s. 210Appeal from Court of Mines — Companies Act 1890 (No. 1074), Part II., ss. 250, 303 — Winding up by Court — Voluntary winding up — Company not having debts.

SARGOOD v. VEALE17 VLR 660

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HODGES, JJ.·30 Nov 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

InformerRight to lay an information for offences against the public at large — Practice in orders to review.

NYULASY v. ROWAN17 VLR 663

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., and HOOD, J.·23 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

ContractConsideration — Continuing offer — Forbearance by plaintiff to sell stock in consequence of offer by defendant.

HANCOCK v. VANDERSTOEL17 VLR 671

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, and HOOD, JJ.·26 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Mines Act 1890 (No. 1120), s. 265Meaning of words "upon the hearing" — Certiorari.

GLENNY v. THE EGLINTON LAND CO. LIMITED17 VLR 676

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and MOLESWORTH, JJ.·11 Aug 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

ArbitrationAward made by two out of three arbitrators — Reception of affidavit made by barrister who acted as arbitrator.

MOORE v. WHEAL BYJERKERNO TIN MINING CO.17 VLR 680

WEBB, J.·8 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"The Mining Companies Act 1871" (No. 409), ss. 50 and 118 (5)"The Forfeiture of Mining Shares Validating Act 1882" (No. 742), s. 7 — No-liability company — Call — Notice of day call payable — Reasonable notice — Forfeited shares — Advertisement of sale — Postponement of sale — Forfeited shares not sold — Fresh resolution for sale — Fresh day appointed for sale — Fresh right to redeem.

HARRIS v. GOLLINGS17 VLR 686

WEBB, J.·10 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

"The Land Act 1884" (No. 812), s. 65Land Act 1890 (No. 1106), s. 65 — License of auriferous land — Vendor and purchaser — Tenure stated at auction sale — Mistake of purchaser — Vendor having no title at time of sale — Specific performance — Condition of license — Enclosing with good and substantial fence — Renewal of license — Expiry of time for sending in requisitions — Negotiations as to title after time gone by — Waiver — Sale of more than 20 acres of auriferous land — Compensation clause — Deficiency in area — Void sale.

MUNRO AND BAILLIEU v. ADAMS17 VLR 703

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., WEBB, A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·13 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Transfer of Land Act 1890 (No. 1149)Lessor and lessee — Covenant not to sub-let without lessor's consent — Sub-lease without consent — Covenant to pay rent — Sub-lease not registered — Action to recover rent — Subsequent registration of sub-lease — Use and occupation.

GRAVES v. THE COUNTY ESTATES CO. LIMITED17 VLR 712

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·13 Oct 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

"The Land Tax Act 1877" (No. 575)Land tax — Vendor of landed estate — Purchaser of allotment less than taxable area — Liability of purchaser for land tax.

MILLER v. HANSON17 VLR 715

HODGES, J.·26 Nov 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

PracticeOrder XXXVI., rr. 32 and 33 — Trial of action — Absence of counsel — No appearance for plaintiff through mishap — Judgment for defendant, with costs — Application to reinstate the case.

IN RE COMPANIES ACT 189017 VLR 717

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·9 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

The Companies Act 1890 (No. 1074)Issue of paid-up shares — Shares — Contributories — Memorandum of association.

GILCHRIST v. GILCHRIST17 VLR 724

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J.·16 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marriage Act 1890 (No. 1166), ss. 87, 96Order for permanent alimony — Attachment for non-payment of alimony — Jurisdiction — Form of order.

TEVELEIN v. TEVELEIN AND HUNTER17 VLR 727

A’BECKETT, J.·14 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marriage Act 1890 (No. 1166), s. 86Dissolution of marriage — Adultery of wife — Husband's conduct conducing to adultery — "Wilful misconduct."

RUSSELL v. RUSSELL17 VLR 729

WEBB, J.·15 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

TrusteesBreach of trust — Wilful default — Accounts on the footing of wilful default — Loss to the estate.

ARMSTRONG v. NEWEY17 VLR 734

WEBB, J.·18 Sept 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Administration actionOrder XVI., r. 33 — Parties — Action by one next-of-kin, others not joined — Foreign administration — Foreign estate — Administrator within jurisdiction.

MITCHELL & CO. v. JOSHUA BROS.17 VLR 736

HODGES, J.·3 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Trade Marks Act 1890 (No. 1146), s. 6Trade mark — Label — Parts in common use — Whole distinctive — Infringement of trade mark — Registration for five years — Defence — Trading on reputation of plaintiff — Injunction.

CURWEN v. YAN YEAN LAND CO. LIMITED17 VLR 745

HIGINBOTHAM, C.J., A’BECKETT, and HOOD, JJ.·19 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court)

Vendor and purchaserLand company — Shareholder — Promoter — Concealment — Misrepresentation — Concealment of vendor — Form of relief — Qualified rescission — Restitution — Indemnity — Damages.

RICHARDS v. RICHARDS17 VLR 758

HODGES, J.·7 Dec 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Marriage Act 1890 (No. 1166), s. 74 (c.)Dissolution of marriage — Frequent convictions for crime — Imprisonment in aggregate for three years or upwards.

SHAW v. BRODIE AND CARTER17 VLR 760

A’BECKETT, J.·30 June 1891·Supreme Court of Victoria

Vendor and purchaserContract for sale of land — Assignee of purchaser — Promissory notes of assignee — No release of purchaser — Dishonour of promissory notes — Conditions of sale — Material alterations after assignment — Re-sale on default — Deficiency in price — Waiver against purchaser.